Showing posts with label intelligence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label intelligence. Show all posts

Friday, May 6, 2011

The Bush Administration's Profoundly Awful Intelligence Policies Actually Prevented the CIA from Finding bin Laden

It shouldn't come as any surprise that many supporters of former President Bush are now rushing to sing the praises of the policies that killed Osama bin Laden, and while the prominence of the sexier of those policies -- enhanced interrogation, indefinite detention, rendition, etc. -- is still murky at the moment, there is one policy that conservatives seemed to have forgotten: the Bush administration's all-out war with the Central Intelligence Agency.

Starting some time in the first half of 2002, CIA was on the losing end of just about every bureaucratic struggle it fought with the White House. Some folks blame Donald Rumsfeld for this, the theory being that CIA's successful invasion of Afghanistan made the Pentagon look bad. Whatever the causes, there can be little denying that CIA's relationship with the White House was so abysmal that it's little wonder bin Laden wasn't found until after Bush left office.

The list of CIA's grievances is extensive. Many analysts thought their portfolios were being taken from them and delivered to the nebulous Office of Special Plans in the Pentagon during the run-up to the Iraq War. VP Cheney apparently applied pressure to Iraq analysts in the Agency to come up with the necessary connections that would build a case for war. And when no weapons of mass destruction were found in Iraq, just about everyone at the Agency felt they were unjustly blamed despite warning the White House before the war.

CIA's relationship to the Bush White House was pretty much over at this point. Bush never seemed to trust the CIA again after the WMD fiasco. There's even reason to suggest that Bush thought elements within CIA were trying to sabotage him political (see the Joe Wilson affair).

The war in Iraq also started to give the Agency fits. First, it distracted them from an already difficult mission in Afghanistan, where bin Laden and much of the leadership of the Taliban were still at large. Then the Iraq insurgency got out of hand and required CIA to devote even more energy and resources to a situation they were never crazy about to begin with. The relationship was so dysfunctional that by the end of 2003 CIA agents were grumbling to the press at an unprecedented level.

2004 got off to a terrible start with the leak of an undercover operative by the White House, an event that many in CIA took to be a petty act of political vengeance. During this time, the Bush White House started developing closer to ties to the National Security Agency, not only because they were in charge of the controversial eavesdropping  program, but also because they operated under the auspices of Rumsfeld's Pentagon. Morale at the agency was apparently awful and made worse by the fact that a number of their operations were outsourced to private contractors who, in many cases, were former Agency employees now working at a significant pay increase.

In the middle of the year DCI George Tenet left and gave Bush the chance to appoint one of his own guys to the Agency. He picked Porter Goss a then-Congressman who brought in his Congressional staff and immediately began butting heads with career intelligence officials, presumably at the behest of the White House. Goss tenure was marked by the departure of enormous swathes of CIA's senior leadership who took with them decades of experience and was largely considered a disaster. He was so awful that Bush even canned him out of the blue one Friday afternoon.

Aside from crushing morale inside the Agency, Goss tenure mas marked by an almost total stripping of authority and prestige when the Intelligence Community was reorganized and the Director of CIA was replaced as de facto leader of the community by the Office of the Director of National Security, which was another huge of the Agency's turf. It was also during Goss' reign that the Iraq insurgency went to hell and the demand for reliable intelligence was at its greatest since the war began, intelligence that was nearly impossible to obtain due to all of the dysfunction back at Langley. Once again, CIA shouldered much of the blame.

Oh yeah, all this time the CIA was put in charge of the enhanced interrogation program even though interrogations had been the purview of the FBI and Army. They had no experience, resisted the program at first and bore all the legal risk.

When Goss was finally shown the door, Bush appoint NSA director Michael Hayden to the post. in 2006 Though Hayden was widely respected in the community, there were concerns about his ties to Rumsfeld and  Pentagon largely because he would still retain his rank in the Air Force (and uniform), even as director of what is ostensibly a civilian agency. Again, most people in the agency interpreted the move to be the Wite House's way of ensuring the primacy of electronic and signals intelligence, both the fortes of NSA, over CIA's human intelligence gathering strengths. This isn't a small detail. Even though the Bush administration increased the budgets of the intelligence community, much of the money apparently went to funding satellites and other electronic intercepting equipment.

Why? Because from the very beginning the Bush Administration was not satisfied with the timeliness of human intelligence, which frequently takes years to develop sources. It was also human intel that created the WMD fiasco in Iraq. They wanted instant gratification and were willing to sacrifice quality for quantity; so instead of training language interpreters, money went to voice pattern recognition software.

Even collecting intelligence on the battlefield played second fiddle to appeasing the social conservative wing of the Bush Administration's political base when the Pentagon kicked out over 60 linguists for being gay.

The final straw occurred when Bush commuted Scooter Libby's sentence in the leak case. There was really no other way to read the move being anything other than a slap in the Agency's face.

The Bush Administration was at war with the intelligence community for a vast majority of Bush's time in office. These policies essentially drove away experience and talent, withheld resources and crippled the Agency's mission at a time when the President said the country needed it most. It is absolutely asinine to suggest that these policies lead to the death of Osama bin Laden.

Tensions only really started to ease when Robert Gates, himself a former DCI, was appointed Secretary of Defense. When Obama appointed Leon Penetta -- a consummate bureaucratic operator -- to be DCI, it was clear he was being brought in to clean up the mess made by the Bush administration. The bin Laden raid was an enormous success for an agency that has been kicked around for most of the last decade.

In the final analysis, the Bush Administration may have had the worst Intelligence policy in American history. They held grudges, didn't learn lessons from mistakes, they deliberately antagonized the very people who were charged with collecting intelligence, they were believed they were better at the job then the experts ... and at the end of the day it all added up to create a situation where the White House really didn't even trust the CIA, the agency that is the final arbiter of what is fact.

And Congress, which is responsible for oversight of the intel community, basically deferred to the White House's lead.

The point is this: it doesn't matter if the intel that helped catch bin Laden came from someone being waterboarded at Gitmo in the big picture. All of the controversial policies that involved tough ethical questions are almost insignificant compared to the massive management policies that the Bush White House botched time and time again. These policies actually prevented CIA from catching bin Laden.

And probably no other policy displays that fact more than the Bush Administation's attitudes toward Pakistan. In Pervez Musharraf, the Bush Administration thought they had an ally and were determined to keep him in power. What they probably didn't consider is that part of the calculus of keeping Musharraf in power may have been the General's ability to placate elements in the Pakistani military that were aiding Al-Qaeda. The Bush Administration let Pakistan dictate the extent of CIA involvement in their country, even though, most people were pretty sure that's where Al-Qaeda was hiding. They may have been correct in trusting Musharraf, but asking a country how many spies the US can keep inside it's borders sort of defeats the entire purpose of espionage.

This was no way to run an intelligence organization.

Friday, December 26, 2008

Sexpionage

The Afghan chieftain looked older than his 60-odd years, and his bearded face bore the creases of a man burdened with duties as tribal patriarch and husband to four younger women. His visitor, a CIA officer, saw an opportunity, and reached into his bag for a small gift.

Four blue pills. Viagra.

"Take one of these. You'll love it," the officer said. Compliments of Uncle Sam.

Whole thing here.

Friday, March 21, 2008

Friday Link Orgy

* John McCain gets closer to opting for public financing of his presidential campaign while Wall Street puts its money on the Democrats, and even GOP 527s seem to be having a hard time of late, but somehow the RNC is doing better than the DNC.

* The merely mildly amusing web site Stuff White People Like has been getting a lot of flack lately, but it's also getting an outrageous advance for a book deal. We can only hope the infinitely superior Hot Chicks with Douchebags got a better deal.

* Hey, now you too can shill for your blog on the pages of the Washington Post! Chris Cillizza at The Fix is looking to round up the best political blogs in each of the 50 states and I see the folks over at RealDebateWisconsin and the BadgerBloggerAlliance have already dispatched their minions. Sorry, folks that's not what he's looking for. My guess is that WisPolitics.com and/or the Wheeler Report will win.

* Explore a lost city on your lunch break today.

* A brief look at how the war in Iraq is dissuading the next generation of military leadership in the Army and Marines from re-upping.

* Bad news for Obama? I would imagine it would be even worse news for the State Dept.

* Silly drunk people ...

* There is still an ungoldly amount of spying going on in Russia ... even in the private sector.

* Ricky Gervais might be in the middle of making one of the funniest movies of all time ... no pressure.

Sunday, March 16, 2008

Sunday Morning Link Orgy

* The London Telegraph tells you how to get to the World's 50 Best Works of Art (some back-breaking travel required).

* DNI Mike McConnell opens up to a group of Johns Hopkins students on the nature of the Intelligence business.

* The Virginia Quarterly Review passes on 27 Reasons Why Short Stories are Rejected (Reason #1: Your story sucks).

* The Clinton campaign and the conference call: a love affair in three acts.

* Has science found a way to end to end the practice of war?

* Did you know Kareem Abdul-Jabbar blogs for the L.A. Times?

* Superdelegates: they could feasibly end the whole nominating process for the Dems right now if they wanted to (but they don't).

Wednesday, February 6, 2008

I'm Taking this Guy to Vegas with Me

The American intelligence community's problems may be legion, but predicting the outcome of football games is not one of them. Here was DCI Gen. Michael Hayden's SuperBowl prediction:

Giants, 28-24. The spread favors the Pats, but careful intelligence work looks beyond the obvious. The Giants are hot now. Three playoff wins on the road (like the Steelers before Super Bowl XL). Regular season finale shows they match up well against the Pats. Besides, nobody's perfect!

The "nobody's perfect" bit at the end was a nice touch ...

Other notables who have good football instincts: Soul singer and Psychic Friends Hotline pitchwoman Dionne Warwick, Dolph Lundgren (no joke), Pat Robertson (yes, that Pat Robertson), Miss USA (but not Miss America), and Placido Domingo.

Monday, January 28, 2008

Monday Night Link Orgy

Hey, did you happen to know that someone's giving a speech tonight?

Well, neither did I, which leads me to side with John Cole in believing that this is possibly the least hyped State of the Union address I can remember. On the one hand, that's too bad for President Bush. Usually his State of the Union speeches are about as good as his oratory gets (I think it has a lot to do with the large amount of preparation time he gets relative to other addresses). Then again, maybe the White House thought they could simply fly under the radar this year and hope no one would notice.

In any event, if you're not interested in watching Bush's last State of the Union, here is some alternative reading:

* Lots of buzz about Spencer Ackerman's article in the newly launched Washington Independent on the CIA's feeble interrogation capabilities prior to 9/11 and what "enhancing" those techniques has done to the agency.

* Speaking of interrogation, if you did not see last night's 60 Minutes, check out the absolutely captivating segment on FBI agent George Piro, the man responsible for interrogating Saddam Hussein. It's an absolutely hypnotic story that will surely be coming to a theater near you some time in the future.

* The cultural importance of Rambo, from the original 1972 novel to the current film.

* The life of rogue economist Hyman Minsky, whom The Chief noted back in August when we were warning anyone who would listen of the impending financial disaster I'm sure we'll hear President Bush speak about tonight ...

* The quarterly journal World Affairs is back in circulation (again) and the first issue is packed with heavy weights: Christopher Hitchens, Alan Wolfe, and George Packer among them.

* A look at Third Coast Studios, soon to be Wisconsin's only bona fide commercial movie studio.

* Finally, a look at the Obama and Clinton strategies for winning on Super Tuesday at New York Magazine, which is best goddamn publication in America right now, so far as I'm concerned.

Saturday, January 26, 2008

Saturday Night Link Orgy

* An example of how the WGA is winning the PR war in the writer's strike.

* In search of the Ur-Hamlet.

* Gazprom is looking to corner the European gas market.

* The Phoenix Suns will play a preseason game outdoors next year.

* South Carolina exit polls and whathaveyou.

* Digital Underground, Tone Loc & Young MC will perform at Dan Majerle's Super Bowl party.

* A U.S. spy satellite is coming back to Earth the hard way.

Friday, January 18, 2008

Friday, December 7, 2007

More Iran NIE Nonsense

John Bolton is on the warpath trying to convince the country the NIE is bullshit, when:

Principal Deputy National Intelligence Director Donald Kerr said Thursday at a House intelligence subcommittee hearing that the Iran report was perhaps the most deeply sourced National Intelligence Estimate ever. The document has over 1,000 footnotes, he said.

(emphasis added)

Even Cheney says he "doesn't have any need to question" the NIE.

Wednesday, December 5, 2007

Wisco Reacts to the Iran NIE

While I'm not terribly surprised that may on the right side of the Cheddarsphere are going down with the Bush Administration's foreign policy ship, it is interesting to note just how they are spinning what can only be seen as a unequivocal embarrassment for the President.

Yesterday I looked at how the rest of the world was responding to the Iran NIE, so now it only seems reasonable to take a look at the local reaction:

Mary Eden doesn't think the Democrats have done enough to get tough on Iran's belligerent language:

It really makes me sick that these Dem candidates prefer to bash Bush and the "neocons" for saber-rattling rather than holding Ahmadinejad accountable for his defiance of the world community and his threatening, inflammatory rhetoric.



Never mind the fact that American neocons aren't saber-rattling -- they actually want to bomb Iran. The Iranians, on the other hand, can't really be accused of saber-rattling because -- thank God -- it turns out they don't have a saber to rattle. Little details like this are good to know when engaging in international affairs.

Jessica McBride pens an absolutely incomprehensible post on the matter that begins with this breath-taking lede:

Funny how it's now the Democrats who are staking crucial foreign policy questions by assuming the validity of national intelligence estimates, this time relating to Iran.

Funny? Are they simply supposed to ignore NIEs all together? Most Democrats assumed the validity of the last NIE and developed their policy positions around that intelligence product. Now, it turns out that the original NIE was incorrect, but that the reality of the revised NIE actually give greater credence to their position ... and it's not the Democrats that are wrong, but it's the NIE? McNride is going to have to do better than that.

She should start by reconsidering the very next thing she says:

Let's hope those intelligence estimates - much assailed by Democrats for their past inaccuracy on Iraq - are right this time.

What does she by "assailed"? They were proven to be wrong. The intelligence that was used as the reason for going to war with Iraq was "vetted" through a special Pentagon team known as the Office of Special Plans, which has been the subject of much criticism since the beginning of the invasion. In today's Washington Post David Ignatius dishes on how the CIA set up a special internal office -- free from political pressure -- to evaluate Iranian nuclear capabilities. In other words, this report is the product of intelligence analysis as it is intended to be done.

But, none of this really matters to McBride, because the flawed Iraqi intel is meaningless:

I'd rather have the situation in Iraq, than inaction based on estimates that are wrong and consequently end up with a nuclear Iran in my lifetime. At least in Iraq, we deposed a belligerent tyrant who gassed women and children and wanted to get nukes to destroy Israel.

You heard it here first, folks: Jessica McBride, cunning strategic thinker that she is,wants more cowbell in the Middle East.

Patrick McIlheran carries water for several prominent neocons, who are basically saying, "But how can we trust this NIE?" Well, the burden of proof is now on you guys and short of plucking a Shahab Missile with one of those atomic symbols painted on the side out of Tehran, no one will believe the Bomb Iran crowd. McIlheran also parrots much of Bush's absolutely embarrassing press conference yesterday by reminding is readers that this NIE shows that at least Iran did have a nuclear program and blah blah blah ...

McIlheran even goes so far as to lap up the sheer bullshit that the NIE actually represents a victory for the Bush doctrine:

But, as Joscelyn and Victor Davis Hanson both say, the natural question now is that if Iran indeed did stop working on a nuke in 2003, might that show "that Iran, like Libya, likely came to a conjecture (around say early spring 2003?) that it was not wise for regimes to conceal WMD programs, given the unpredictable, but lethal American military reaction"?

This is nothing like Libya. If Iran's ending of its nuclear program was contingent on the success of the U.S. invasion of Iraq, why didn't it restart the program back up when the American troops began to get bogged down and it appeared increasing impossible for the military to conduct three separate wars in three different countries in the Middle East? Wouldn't that be more demonstrative of a genuine intent to create a nuclear program?

These are essentially the three tracks that the right is using to defend what is without question a humiliating, if not catastrophic, loss of American credibility in the international arena. We've been discussing possible hostile action against Iran for several years now in exactly the same way that the dialog over Iraq was conducted before the invasion. Despite the lessons we should have learned from our misadventures in Baghdad, the Bush Administration came close to falling into the same trap again.

It's not the Democrats, it's not the intelligence community, it's not the foreign policy establishment, its not the media -- but it is the Bush Administration. Oddly enough, Bush is missing from many posts against the Iran NIE, which should be seen as an almost conscious unwillingness to discuss the most local aspect of this development -- the President's utter incompetence with foreign affairs.

See this discussion between former CIA official Larry Johnson and ex-diplomat Victor Comras. Comras brings up the canard that Iranian leadership can not be trusted to make "rational" decisions. This argument now gets increasingly less credible in light of the new NIE because US intel is now saying that that Iran has, in fact, made a very rational decision by giving up its nuclear program in 2003.

MORE: Kevin Drum on the Ignatius article ... Iran scholar Farideh Farhi on Bush's press conference ... Matt Dupius is tracking developments ... Haaretz: "The time has come for U.S. to persue talks with Iran"... Joe Scarborough gets in on the action ... Shaun Mullen on Cheney's role:

There are indications that Cheney tried to suppress the NIE findings, which the White House has known about for at least a month or two as the noise machine shifted into higher gear with “leaked” reports of fleet maneuvers in the Persian Gulf and preparations for military strikes. When the veep was unable to halt release of a summary of the report, he successfully blocked release of key findings that would further embarrass the administration.

And then National Security Advisor Stephen Hadley delivered the coup de grâce by claiming that the report didn’t undercut the administration’s hysterical war-drum beating. Besides which, it wasn’t completed until a few days ago. (Wink, wink. Nod, nod.)

And George Friedman (here, too) has a few things to say.

EVEN MORE: This is too rich!

For a thorough on-going examination of the NIE check out the Arms Control Wonk, Jeffery Lewis.

People the World Should Start Paying More Attention To

Jonathan Landay.

Tuesday, December 4, 2007

Tomorrow's Excuses Today

In the wake of the disastrous release of the Iran nuclear NIE, there are several prominent neoconservatives screaming at the top of their lungs that the U.S. intelligence community is, in fact, wrong. One is Norman Podhoretz. Another is John Bolton. The Weekly Standard is equally unrepentant ... I'm sure in the days to come more will make their displeasure at the CIA known.

A few weeks ago, U.S. counterintelligence a former employee of the FBI and CIA plead guilty to spying for Hizbollah. The Iranian Revolutionary Gaurd help to establish Hizballah in Lebanon in the early 1980s and has maintained strong ties since. It should come as no surprise, then, when the recent NIE is inevitably dismissed as a mismanaged consequence of this security breach by some neocons.

I would seriously doubt if there is a legitimate connection.

Friday, September 28, 2007

Oops!

If true, this would have to qualify as one of the greatest security breaches in the annals of intelligence:

The Macedonian intelligence agency denies claims made by the country's largest daily newspaper, Dnevnik, that one of its counter-intelligence analysts has stolen the agency's database on undercover operatives, fled the country and sold the information to Bulgarian secret services.

[...]

The Dnevnik report claims that the alleged theft of counter-intelligence information has compromised the entire Macedonian intelligence network and is likely to take two decades to rebuild. The story quotes unnamed sources within the Macedonian Interior Ministry, underscores longstanding tensions between Bulgaria and Macedonia and highlights potential instability within the Macedonian government.

This is a plot from which movies are made (see the first Mission: Impossible).

And while we're on the subject of Eastern European espionage ...

Turns out that everyone and their mother in the old East Germany was spying for the West:

It's a well-known fact that East Germany had agents crawling all over West Germany during the Cold War. Up to 6,000 of them, some in high places, were regularly passing information eastwards across the wall.

According to a new study published on Friday, though, when it came to recruiting spooks, the West Germans were even better. Fully 10,000 citizens of Germany's communist half were spying for Bonn. Not only that, but West Germany's intelligence agency the Bundesnachrichtendienst (BND) had a pretty good idea about the plans to build the Berlin Wall, but their bosses in Bonn simply didn't want to believe them.

Also noteworthy, hiring Nazis to do a little freelance spying ... not a very good idea:

The U.S. government apparently derived no clear benefit by recruiting ex-Nazis as Cold War spies, but potentially huge gaps remain in the public record of U.S. ties to World War Two war criminals, according to a report issued on Friday.

The report to Congress, by an interagency group that examined the United States' use of German and Japanese war criminals during and after the war, also said the CIA had no set policy for hiring former war criminals to spy on postwar foes including the Soviet Union.

[...]

Elizabeth Holtzman, a former New York congresswoman and member of the panel, said the group received files on about 60,000 former Nazi and Japanese war criminals but did not have the names of all collaborators, particularly those in Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union.

[...]

"It is not clear that Nazis provided us with any useful intelligence, and we know that in some cases at least they were a serious detriment to us," she added. "Given the intelligence failures of the Iraq war, it might be important for U.S. policymakers to understand that using very bad people for intelligence activities does not automatically get us very good results, and instead, may get us very bad results," Holtzman said.

Thursday, September 13, 2007

Bill Belicheck, Take Note

A suspension and loss of a draft pick is nothing:

The McLaren-Mercedes Formula One team was on Thursday night fined $100m – a sum unprecedented in sport – and thrown out of this year’s F1 constructors’ championship by motor sport’s top judicial body.

The FIA World Motor Sport Council took the action after finding the Anglo-German team, which until Thursday night led the competition, guilty of fraudulent behaviour relating to a technical dossier belonging to rival Ferrari which was found in the possession of a senior employee.


MORE: The Commish merely fines the Pats.

EVEN MORE: Daniel Drezner asks:

A question to the three people in the known universe who are acolytes of both Formula One racing and the National Football League: While even I can determine that McLaren's actions were more egregious than Belichick's, were they 200 times as egregious??

Friday, September 7, 2007

... And Speaking of WMD

Hilzoy picks up on this Salon piece.

Expect more of this type of thing: lower level career government employees speaking more freely to the press about controversial topics as the clock runs out on the Bush administration. Now that the President's Texas Praetorian Guard has left for the private sector the new guys will likely be too busy putting out actual fires to enforce the loyalty blood oath and vow of silence they demand of all government officials.

MORE: See what I mean ...

Wednesday, September 5, 2007

Well, Now that You Mention It ...

That is an interesting coincidence ...

The link to Larry Johnson's post does indeed offer "one compelling case of circumstantial evidence," but, ultimately, that's all it is.

Nevertheless, it is an interesting coincidence ...

MORE: Josh Marshall checks up on the issue and determines it's just a coincidence.

Monday, September 3, 2007

Oops!

Someone at Naval Counterintelligence is probably filling out a lot of paperwork over this picture.

Monday, August 27, 2007

A Spy in the House of Representatives?

Actually, there have probably been plenty. The most notable of recent years was Porter Goss, the ill-fated DCI who failed to "clean up" CIA when appointed by Bush to succeed George Tenet.

But beleaguered out-going Rep. Rick Renzi?

Sunday, August 26, 2007

We Must Protect this House (of Saud)!

Read this article from FT on the Saudi Arabian effort to train an "oil infrastructure defense force." Check out how the author describes what recruits are being trained to do:

The force already numbers about 5,000 personnel, a Saudi adviser said on Sunday. They are being trained in the use of new surveillance equipment, countermeasures and crisis management under a programme managed by US defence group Lockheed Martin, according to the Middle East Economic Survey in Nicosia.

The recruits are learning about laser security and satellite imaging from Lockheed on behalf of the Sandia National Laboratories’ Defense Systems and Assessments Unit – a US government run unit in New Mexico, said MEES.

[scene missing]

Members of the new force, responsible for external and internal security, are being heavily vetted and largely recruited from outside the security forces because of the nature of its task, but it will include members of the existing forces.

(emphasis mine)

I must be confused with what is exactly meant by "external and internal security" here. Are we talking about inside and outside the refineries and other facilities? Or are we talking about inside and outside the country?

On one level the foreign/domestic nature of this security detail would make some sense since Saudi Arabia is, after all, an oil exporting country and getting the oil from point A to point B is half the battle (hey, there are still pirates in those international waters).

But on another level this description sounds like the Saudis are establishing a kind of petro-CIA. Saudi Intelligence (the General Intelligence Directorate or, in Arabic, Mukhabarat) has a reputation for operating more like a bank than spy agency -- at least when it was run by Turki al-Faisal -- and I know very little of how it handles domestic intelligence issues (but I can take a guess), so it's interesting to see the country organize this kind of hands-on security force instead of just bribing foreigners all the time.

I'm kind of curious about the other kinds of training these guys will get -- i.e. will they all become experts in petroleum fire-fighting techniques too?

Tuesday, August 21, 2007

Hackers, Start Your (Search) Engines

I wonder how long this idea will last in practice:

The Director of National Intelligence will open the site to the entire intelligence community in December. The move is the latest part of an ongoing effort to transform the analytical business following the failure to detect the 9/11 terrorist attacks or find weapons of mass destruction in Iraq.

Thomas Fingar, the deputy director of national intelligence for analysis, believes the common workspace – a kind of “MySpace for analysts” – will generate better analysis by breaking down firewalls across the traditionally stove-piped intelligence community. He says the technology can also help process increasing amounts of information where the number of analysts is limited.

I give it a year, tops.