Showing posts with label government. Show all posts
Showing posts with label government. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 3, 2010

Is There Too Much Democracy in America?

John Bernstein's piece at the Daily Dish seems to be getting a lot of attention today. After voting for 52 separate officials in yesterday's Texas primary he concludes:
I love elections, and I do believe that one mark of a strong democracy is keeping the politicians, and not bureaucracies, in charge of lots of things.

But this is ridiculous. The correct word for most of the elections that happened in Texas today, and that happen in primary elections around the nation all spring and summer this year, is farce. No one has any idea what they're doing (especially in primaries, and in nonpartisan elections, in which you don't even get a useful cue about what to do). I like the idea that Americans vote more often and for more things that just about any other nation, but we could vote for about a third of what we vote for now and still be very high on the scale, and people wouldn't have to fee[l] like idiots on election day. I've never heard a good defense for most of it, and I really think we should cut it out.

The Economist also chimes in with another example of democracy overkill.

So how much is too much?

We went looking and found an outdated figure that says there were a whopping 511,039 elected officials in America ... and that was only in 1992! (We're sure it's gotta be more today.) That means about 1 in every 600 people holds some kind of elected office in America.

So today we're trying to add up all the folks we vote for on a regular basis. There's almost a 100% chance that we're missing someone, so feel free to help us out in the comments section:

Federal (4)
1 President of the United States*
2 Senators
1 Representative to the House
*We're omitting VPOTUS because he is selected by the candidate.

State (14)
1 Governor
1 Lt. Governor (who is selected in a party primary)
1 Secretary of State
1 Attorney General
1 Department of Public Instruction head
7 Supreme Court Justices
1 State Assembly person
1 State Senator
County (13)
1 County Executive
1 Representative to the County Board
1 Clerk of Courts
1 Coroner
1 District Attorney
1 Sheriff
1 Registrar of Deeds**
6 County Circuit Court Judges
** We think.

Municipal (14)

7 City Council members (All local council members are elected at-large)
7 school board members
That's 45 offices I vote for on a regular basis. (Maybe more, maybe less ... we'll see.) Less than what Mr. Bernstein had to endure yesterday and much less than what he has to endure during a given election cycle. A friend from Chicago claims to have voted for roughly 150 offices in one ballot recently ... so believe what of that as you will.

Tell us what you think: is 45 (give or take) too many, too few or just right? How many people do you vote for where you live? Are you happy with that number, want to expand it or think it should be curtailed? What offices should we continue to vote for and for which ones is voting unnecessary?

MORE: I don't know if anyone else noticed this, but there are only 183 elected offices in the entire state of Hawaii, by far the fewest in the country. It's entirely possible that there are as many in Winnebago county alone. In case you're curious, there are 165,000 people in Winnebago County and 1.3 million people in the state of Hawaii -- that's one office (even counting dog-catcher) for every 7100 people.

Accordingly, Hawaii tends to rank fairly high in terms of corruption in relation to its population.

MORE STILL: Just for the sake of crunching some more useless numbers, using the '92 office figures with today's most recent population figures 1 in every 305 Illinois residents holds elected office. In Pennsylvania, it's 1 in every 414. Unlike Hawaii, these are respectively the 5th and 6th most populous states in the country.

Monday, January 11, 2010

The Voluntary Voter Disenfranchisement Act

The Kanavas/Kramer Voluntary Voter ID bill seems, at best, kinda superfluous to me and potentially reckless, at worse. Here's what it does:
Under the bill, citizens concerned about having their vote stolen could enroll in a voluntary voter ID program. Here's how it would work: You go to your municipal clerk's office and opt-in to the program by signing a registration card and producing a photo ID. On Election Day, the poll worker will ask you for your photo ID before he or she hands you a ballot. Then you vote. It's that simple.
If a voter was so concerned about his or her vote being stolen, wouldn't it just be easier to go to the municipal clerk and early vote once the ballots came back from the printers? There seems to be an easier way to do this than to make voters go to up to two different locations to fill out one little ballot.

Second, is this even a problem? I looked around for newspaper accounts of someone not being allowed to vote in Wisconsin because someone had already voted using his or her name and couldn't find one account. Obviously, this doesn't mean that it hasn't happened, but it suggests it's not much more than an anomaly.

Lastly, and most importantly, this seems like a really easy way to disenfranchise other people from voting. If my name is John Smith and I register to vote in a precinct in Milwaukee that has many John Smiths, what are the odds that there will be some confusion -- legitimate or otherwise -- regarding which John Smiths, or even others people named Smith, are in the program and which aren't? It's conceivable that every Smith in a given voting district could suddenly be required to show photo ID at the polls just because one person signed up for the program. Since it's not uncommon for the extended families of minority and/or poor families, who share last names, to live in the same neighborhoods -- and by extension, the same voting precincts -- this could have an adverse effect on groups have a long history of having their votes suppressed by needlessly complicating the voting system and opening the door to a whole new kind of vote blocking. (If Smith seems like too generic an example, think about someone with the surname of Xiong.)

Proponents will argue that it's a voluntary program, but that's exactly what makes it so problematic. What's to prevent John Smith from registering for the program in dozens of precincts, but only voting in one? By not exiting the program in each of the precincts he doesn't vote in, he could be making life very difficult for potential namesakes in those other precincts. And that's just an extreme example of someone with clearly fraudulent intentions. There could be a multiplier effect from voters just being mobile during the course of their lives.

I'm sure the authors of the bill will play this off as a kind of insurance policy for voters, but in order to genuinely protect the vote the rules have to apply uniformly, otherwise voters with "special protections" will almost invariably have the opportunity to game the system.

Thursday, December 10, 2009

More on the Oshkosh Corp./BAE Feud

Man, this thing just keeps going ... it's now moved on from the regional and trade press to the august (web)pages of Politico, where I can't help but get the feeling that OC gets the short shrift from the article and others like it.

Left unsaid if the fact that the Texas Congressional delegation is really fighting a fight that they have already lost. SECDEF Gates' trip to Oshkosh to praise workers was a pretty strong indication that the Pentagon is happy with the new MATVs. Also omitted: Oshkosh Corp. has been ahead of schedule in delivering the vehicles -- for the fifth month in a row -- which seems to answer one of the principle questions raised by the Texans.

Let's face it: this is about saving face and appearing to fight for jobs. I can't blame congressmen from a district which just lost lucrative defense contracts for doing everything they can to keep those jobs and don't expect them to give up the fight until the last truck of the contract rolls off the assembly line, but at some point empty gestures like these appear unfair to the folks who lost their jobs and are holding out hope that they might get them back or to the workers who now worry about potentially losing their own jobs. In the grand scheme of things those are probably small factors in a larger political calculus, but it might behoove a news service to help determine just where that line is.

Wednesday, September 16, 2009

"Seriously."

"Tea Party Protesters Protest D.C. Metro Service"

... and without a single hint of irony too!

Thursday, September 10, 2009

"I'm so excited! I'm so ... scared!"

Obviously, health care reform can only be tackled by a congress that can make a campy sitcom look prophetic.


[Via memeorandum]

Saturday, September 5, 2009

The Tyranny of the Wisconsin Secretary of State (?)

Randy Melchert is someone we typically don't see eye-to-eye with, but we have to give him credit for making a strong case that the Wisconsin Secretary of State is, at best, an archaic, nebulous and unnecessary position that probably should be eliminated. We agree with him, but the more we looked into just what the SoS does, the more we started to realize that the SoS isn't a superfluous office, but is potentially one of the most important and powerful offices in Wisconsin precisely because it's parameters are so nebulous.

To understand this, we need to first look at the job of a notary. Notaries public are the law's way of preempting any challenge to a legal document's legitimacy. Armed with those nifty embossing stamps, notaries are America's authenticators.

Now notaries are supposed to be dispassionate observers. Their job is to witness an act and authenticate said act. It's not their job to judge the virtue of that act. For example, Bill is divorcing his wife and needs the divorce papers notarized before the divorce is final. He goes to Steve the Notary and signs the papers in his presence. Steve witnesses it, authenticates it, does his thing with the stamp and ... voila, Bill is now back on the prowl. It doesn't matter what Steve thinks of Bill's divorce -- all the notary has to worry about is authenticating the signature.

But what if a notary did care about the divorce? What if Steve refuses to authenticate the divorce papers because he thinks Bill and his wife would be better served if they just went to counseling? The practical solution to this problem is that Bill just goes to another notary and since there are thousands of them it's not exactly a chore to find a more amenable verifier, just an inconvenience.

But what if there were only one notary? It's kind of an odd thought since notaries are a dime a dozen, but that's exactly the position the state government finds itself in with respect to legislation. State governments need to have their legal documents authenticated just like everyone else, after all.

The Secretary of State is essentially a notary public, except he has one client: the state of Wisconsin. That's what is meant by the phrase "to keep the Great Seal of the State of Wisconsin and affix it to all official acts of the Governor" in the SoS's job description. The SoS is the Governor's independent authenticator. Affixing the state seal is the law-making equivalent of a notary stamping a legal document. The SoS also has another important job: "Wisconsin's Constitution requires the Secretary of State to maintain the official acts of the Legislature and Governor."

This explains why the SoS needs to be directly elected by the people of Wisconsin. SoS can't be appointed by the Governor because then the SoS would no longer be "independent." (In principle, at least. SoS have been appointed in the past to finished terms left by deceased office holders.) Likewise, the Lieutenant Governor can't do the job as things currently stand because the LG runs on the same ticket as the Gov.

Think of the SoS as the quality control expert of the legislative process: he's the guy voters hire to say, "Yup, that all happened the way it was supposed to" at the end of the law-making process. If laws were jackets made by the Gap, the Secretary of State would be Inspected By 23.

But what would happen if, like Steve the Notary from earlier, the SoS decided not to affix the seal of the state of Wisconsin to an act of the Governor? What if an "activist Secretary of State" objected to a piece of legislation and decided not to validate by either affixing the seal (i.e. "notarizing" it) or publish and "maintain" the official acts of the legislature?

Then what?

The only thing that anyone can seem to say with certainty about such a hypothetical situation is that no one knows.

There's no precedent. It simply hasn't happened before, but such a scenario does pose some interesting paradoxes.

First, what can the Governor do? Not much. Because SoS is an independently elected office, the Gov. can't fire him. Furthermore, any executive orders to reign in the SoS would need to be authenticated by the SoS for them to become legal, and there's likely little chance that an SoS would authenticate something that would screw him or her.

Could the legislature impeach the SoS? Possibly, but in order for an act of the legislature to become official it needs to be published by ... the SoS (!), so there's some question as to the authority such an act would carry.

The most likely solution to the problem would be a lawsuit -- filed by the Governor, the legislature, the Attorney General or possibly even a sympathetic third party advocacy group -- seeking a court-ordered injunction forcing the SoS to authenticate the neglected document and/or appointing someone who would do so in the event of further SoS intransigence. Even this wouldn't be much of a "solution," because the legal proceedings would invariably be cluttered by the political motivations of the opponents and proponents of whatever act the SoS refused to validate.

In other words, the SoS has what could be referred to as an "Existential Veto." If SoS doesn't like a bill, SoS could simply refuse to acknowledge that it exists and thereby can not be authenticated. But, instead of the bill going back to the legislature for a potential over-ride, the entire law-making machinery of the state grinds to a screeching halt.

So what's stopping Doug LaFollette or any other SoS, for that matter from wielding this power? Common sense, for one thing, and politics for another -- the SoS does have to get re-elected, after all. But for the sake of argument, lets remove both of those variables from the equation and consider the following hypothetical: an anti-tax advocate wins election to become the next Secretary of State by promising not to authenticate any legislation that includes a tax or fee increase. Would that newly elected SoS have any ground to stand on?

No one knows. That part of Wisconsin government has yet to be beta-tested. There is no precedent in Wisconsin law to say either way, or so I'm told. There may be, however, precedent in other state's. Earlier this year the Minnesota SoS refused to certify Al Franken's election to the U.S. Senate until the legal questions surround his election were reconciled by the courts. This came on the heals of the Illinois SoS refusing to certify the appointment of Roland Burris to the Senate in the wake of the Blagojevich "pay to play" scandal. In both cases, Secretaries of State delayed or refused to make authentications for political reasons -- the overarching question posed by this post is what if those actions were taken to their evolutionary extremes?

So is it really that simple? Does the Wisconsin Secretary of State hang over the legislative process like the sword of Damocles or is all of this merely a precis for a thesis at the Glenn Beck Institute of Art Criticism & Appreciation? Frankly, we don't know, we sure hope this is simply a thought experiment that took a wrong turn and ended up in Crazytown -- and if there's something missing from this train of thought, please, for the love of God, let us know.

There is, however, one thing we can say with certainty: should a SoS ever withhold authentication of legislation to satisfy his or her own personal agenda, it would result in scorched Earth campaign against the office and office holder. The individual would assuredly never get re-elected and the Governor and legislature would team up to end the office altogether. First, all responsibilities would be outsourced to other departments while funding and staff are eliminated from the budget. Then an amendment ridding the state constitution of the office would be drafted and passed and brought to the voters for approval. The problem is that this takes a minimum of six years -- think of how much gridlock a rogue SoS could create if he or she managed to hang on to their office for the four years of their term?

Let's put it another way: if, in fact, all of the above is actually a prerogative of the SoS, then the only thing seperating Wisconsin government from an outright legislative clusterfuck is the temperament of the SoS. That's not exactly what I would call a trustworthy check on power.

Monday, August 3, 2009

Monday, May 18, 2009

Bunker Busted?

Widgerson points to a FoxNews piece on a possible Biden gaffe and while it's certainly a possibility, I'd throw a little more scrutiny on the graph in the Fox piece that reads:
The bunker is believed to be the secure, undisclosed location former Vice President Dick Cheney remained under protection in secret after the 9/11 attacks.
I'd put good money that the source for that belief is Stephen Hayes who said as much in a post at the Weekly Standard. Unfortunately, his determination that the bunker is classified works kind of like this:
*** Dick Cheney and me are tight
*** Cheney never mentioned the bunker to me before
*** Ergo, it must be classified
I'm sorry, but that's comically weak logic, even coming from Cheney's hagiographer. If Hayes had a source that told him the bunker was classified, that would be another thing, but therein lies a conundrum: wouldn't Hayes be just as guilty as Biden for independently confirming the existence of said bunker? So either Hayes is giving his readers a wink and a nod by providing them with a weak rationale or he's passing speculation off as fact.

Whatever is going on here it goes to show the prestidigitation that can occur throughout the media's game of blogger telephone.

Thursday, May 14, 2009

Paul Esslinger, A Real Class Act

A few points on Paul Esslinger's essential dismissal of Ted Bowen and Shirley Maddox from their respects seats on two city boards ...
  • 1.) It was handled in the completely classless way that we should expect from Esslinger.
Maddox and Bowen have both devoted decades to serving the city in various capacities and essentially fall under the category of local "elder statesmen" -- not "good old boys," mind you, but people who have devoted a great deal of time and energy to making this city a better place. Regardless of what anyone may think of their positions on issues, there is little doubt they arrive at them from a sincere desire to make Oshkosh a better place.

Folks like that are very rare in any city and when the time comes for them to move on they deserve to be honored, or at least thanked, for their service. The article makes it clear that neither of them were ready to move on. Now, as it is the mayor's prerogative to appoint people to various city boards, Esslinger has ever right not to re-appoint Bowen and Maddox, but when one does so to people with long records of service a little decorum is required. Esslinger clearly doesn't understand that.

What he should have done was express his intentions to both Bowen and Maddox and seek their input on possible successors. Then when the time came to make the changes public, he should have released a statement thanking the two of them for their service. I'm not suggesting Esslinger give them the keys to the City, but a "thank you" was the very least he could have done ... and I mean the absolute minimum.

By the way, this "screw you" attitude Esslinger is so fabulously demonstrating is a significant reason why numerous businesses have decided not to set up stakes in Oshkosh. I'm not saying Esslinger is directly responsible for losing businesses, but his classlessness is indicative of an attitude that has permeated local government and cost the city dearly over the years. How we treat ourselves is usually a reflection of how we treat others and there's no incentive for City Hall to change it's ways when the guy in charge lacks any degree of tact whatsoever.
  • 2.) Esslinger's rationale for the move is equally oblivious.
Here's what Hizzoner had to say about his motives:
“I want to see some debate,” Esslinger said. “I want to see some real debate on issues and not just rubber stamps.”
Get used to that phrase, Oshkosh, because you're going to be hearing it a lot. Esslinger could have said "fresh ideas," "new blood," or even "contrarian views." Instead he said "debate," which is to say he just wants people that will argue -- not produce their own ideas or solutions -- just argue. He wants "obstructionists," you could say.

What makes this stranger is that Bowen was actually the last thing from a rubber stamp during his time on the Parks board. In fact, Bowen was arguably the most "conservative" member of the board. I use "conservative" in the old fashioned sense that he was extremely resistant to change. There were a ton of very popular initiatives that Bowen opposed much to the frustration of other members of the board. By Esslinger's own definition Bowen is the kind of person he should want sitting on the board. While not quite the contrarian Bowen was, Maddox always did her due diligence and had valid reasons for voting the way she did. Her famously sunny disposition, enthusiasm and optimism were also a valuable asset in a town that is typically dour and pessimistic when it comes to things like development.

So when Esslinger implies that Bowen and Maddox are "rubber stamps" he's basically saying that they are either too stupid to know how to arrive at decisions on their own or, even worse, are being manipulated by forces unseen. It's a pretty odious insult to levy on a pair that have served the city honorably and selflessly for a long time.
  • 3.) Of course it was politically motivated!
Here's when small town politics starts becoming personal -- more like hand-to-hand combat than an exchange of artillery fire. In fact, it's not so much personal as it is downright incestuous.

Bowen's biggest problem isn't his record of service, which as we noted above would appear to be exactly what Esslinger is looking for. It's his wife, school board member Karen Bowen. In certain quarters of Oshkosh, Mrs. Bowen has the reputation for being a bra-burning feminist commie hellbent on raising your tax dollars to indoctrinate your children with atheism or maybe witchcraft (or something). Those who see her as such, probably voted for Paul Esslinger. Getting rid of Mr. Bowen isn't about losing a "rubber stamp;" it's about sticking it to Mrs. Bowen and her supporters, who -- let's be honest here -- probably did not vote for Paul Esslinger.

There's another complication to all of this. One of Karen Bowen's ideological antitheses on the school board is Michelle Monte, part of a husband/wife team that has tied their political fortunes with Esslinger's for some years now. I'm not suggesting that there was a conspiracy between the Montes and Esslinger to boot Bowen from the parks board (that would take a degree of planning that, frankly, I don't think they're capable of), but I am saying that they are smart enough to realize that what's good for one half of the team is good for the other and that Esslinger, to his Machiavellian credit, seized on an opportunity when he was presented with it.

If all of this sounds a little too petty to be believed, just consider this: Bowen's replacement on the Parks board will be Bob Freid, whose record of public service (according to Google, in any event) is rather sparse, save only a public endorsement of ... you got it: Michelle Monte for School Board.

Kent Monte's role in this drama is a bit different. According to one of the comments on the NW thread (so take it with a grain of salt) he served as Esslinger's "campaign manager" or whatever. There's good reason to believe that Kent and Esslinger are of the same mind on a lot of issues, which would make him a good proxy for Paul. As it would happen, Esslinger is no longer allowed to sit on the Planning Commission now that he's Mayor, so there's just such an opening ready to be filled by just such a person.

And as luck would have it, Esslinger's departure coincides with the end of another member's term. During her time on the common council Shirley Maddox came to be identified with the -- ooooohhh, what ridiculous cliche would the Northwestern use that does the city no good and only serves to inflame divisions? oh, yeah -- "wine and cheese" crowd. By replacing her with Monte, Esslinger is pretty obviously throwing a bone to his base, which apparently exists at the opposite end of the Nebulously Defined Socioeconomic Foodstuffs Strata.
  • 4.) Why this is an indication of poor leadership.
As mayor, Esslinger is going to presumably have to work with people who disagree with him on various issues. In other words, Esslinger will not always have the luxury of simply appointing like-minded cronies to positions when they are held by people of a different opinion. If he can't get his way in the future, as is inevitable, how will he react?

The smart money is on "not well," but I'm going to put all my chips on "by taking his ball and going home."
  • 5.) Here's the thing: On one level this is just politics ... but on another, it's not.
Every new "executive" is going to appoint people he knows and trusts to positions that fall under his or her purview. The dirty little secret about the federal government is that there are probably thousands of people around the country who can successfully be the Secretary of the Interior, but the President is going to pick someone from that pool that he knows and trusts.

That's not necessarily "dirty politics" or a quid pro quo so much as responsible team building. You can get away with that at the federal and even state level, but not in a city like Oshkosh. We're too small and the talent pool is too shallow. Appointments start to become crooked when people are provided positions of power who aren't competent and/or when they replace people who are for politically motivated reasons. Time will tell if the former is true, but the current circumstance certainly suggest the latter is the case.

While there is definitely a dispassionate political angle to all of this, one that the current mayor clear understands, there is another that Esslinger seems hopelessly oblivious to: Politics is as much about common courtesy as it is about cold-blooded wrangling. That's a concept a classless boor like Esslinger clearly has no comprehension of and we're the poorer for it as a city.
  • 5.) Don't plan on seeing a new council member any time soon.
This is exactly the reason why we urged as much transparancy as humanly possibly during the selection of the next council member.

This is the first of what will surely be a long and distinguished line of Esslinger instigated distractions that will take the focus off of the real issues. If the council has to devote a ton of time to fixing appointments to boards, it certainly won't have the capacity to refill it's own bench. Actually, now the council must fix this mess before moving on to selecting a new member precisely because Esslinger has diminished the council's ability to make appointments by calling into question at least one member's ability to do so in good faith.

Bra. Vo.
  • 6.) Hey Northwestern, why not include a list of all the appointments Esslinger is submitting to the council?
Just a thought, it seems like it would be relevant to the story. [MORE: They've added a link since last I checked.]
  • 7.) There is every reason to believe this is how Paul Esslinger is going to behave throughout the rest of his term as Mayor.
Here it all is in a nut shell, folks. This is the kind of unforced error we should all get used to because we've seen it time and time again from Esslinger and he never quite seems to learn from his mistakes.

Now the question becomes: will the voters in Oshkosh eventually learn from theirs?

Friday, May 8, 2009

Sean Hackbarth Must Answer for his Viral Video Sins

Did anyone at Republican.Senate.Gov actually expect folks to take this shit seriously?



Carmina Burana?

I enjoyed many a hardy laughter...

Thursday, March 26, 2009

Even Gov. Jindal Wants to Keep Louisiana's Film Tax Credits

Louisiana's an interesting case study to look at when it comes to film tax credits. It's smaller than Wisconsin population wise and has a slightly smaller economy in terms of GSP, but it was one of the first states to begin offering film tax credits in 2002.

In fact, Louisiana's plan was far more generous, providing a tax credit to companies that were willing to help create an "entertainment infrastructure" -- i.e. studios, set, production companies with brick and mortor headquarters -- in the state. It worked, and Shreveport, of all places, has become something of a modern Southern movie-making Mecca:

Less than three years after Shreveport became Louisiana's de facto film capital, the city's movie industry is riding high. Thanks to aggressive statewide financial incentives, the casino-friendly city on the Red River has become one of the most attractive and busiest locations in the country for feature film and television production, surpassing Austin, once vaunted as Hollywood South, with stunning speed and volume.

Since late 2005, when Hurricane Katrina forced film production from New Orleans and Baton Rouge to the Shreveport-Bossier City area, Shreveport has seized upon filmmaking almost entirely on the power of a 6-year-old financial incentive program, which offers filmmakers 25 percent cash rebates (or tax credits) for all in-state spending on things like equipment rentals, food service, hotel rooms and, at a lower rate, labor. The primary rebates are five times the rate of Texas movie incentives.

Louisiana's current production tax credits are exactly the same as Wiscosnin's. While the infrastucture incentives have since expired, and with the production credit set to dimminsih over the next few years, Gov. Jindal wants to extend the current rate of production credits:

Jindal said he'll support legislation this spring to prevent those tax credits from expiring. He also said he would back extension of tax credit programs for certain investments on research and development that have benefited chemical and other industries.

The best known tax break is a 25 percent tax credit for movie makers that is scheduled to drop to 20 percent next year and 15 percent in 2012. Jindal said he'll support a bill to keep the tax credit at 25 percent through 2012.

With growth like this it's easy to see why:
  • Employment in Louisiana’s film industry increased at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 22 percent from 2001 to 2007. This compares to a national growth rate of 1.8 percent annually over the same time period. Although the average wages are lower than the national levels, they have increased at an average annual rate of 8.2 percent, much faster than inflation.
  • Motion picture projects that received state tax credits generated $26.4 million in state and local tax revenue during 2007, of which approximately two-thirds ($14.6 million) went to the State of Louisiana.
  • According to the Louisiana Economic Development Department, there are several applications pending certification for infrastructure development which were submitted before the program expired. Combined, the estimated budgets for the 54 proposed film studio projects are worth nearly $3.2 billion.
And here's probably the most important figure:
  • State of Louisiana will issue an estimated $115 million in tax credits for projects with certified and estimated expenditures incurred during 2007. Combined these projects had an estimated $429 million in qualified expenditures which generated a total economic benefit to the State of $763 million. This represents an economic stimulus of $6.64 for every $1 in tax credits issued for qualifying motion picture expenditures during 2007.
That's not a small multiplier and it's going straight back into the economy.

Stuff Wisconsin Could Buy for the Money it Paid Out in Film Tax Credits Last Year (Vol. I)

6 substandard Government Accountability Board websites from a Connecticut-based IT firm.

Wednesday, March 25, 2009

How the Commerce Department is Killing the Film Tax Credits

There's an epic irony in the fact that "Public Enemies," a movie about a folk hero who tapped into the populist sentiment of the Depression era by robbing banks, is now posed to be the target of that same populist rage here in Wisconsin. I assume the producers weren't planning on this happening when they decided to film in the state, but since the film, which is still months from even being released, has become a pivotal player of sorts in the debate over the film tax credits it's probably worthwhile to take a closer look at the plot of this drama.

Gov. Doyle is nothing if not an extremely shrewd politician. Reasonable people can argue over his skills as a leader, but there is little doubt he is in possession of an adroit political mind. Doyle sent out a trial balloon about repealing (or altering) the tax credits a little over a month ago. Since then he's stayed the hell away from the issue himself and cast someone else in the role of the bill's executioner.

Enter Zach Brandon.

Here's Brandon is in yesterday's Chicago Trib:
State Commerce Department executive assistant Zach Brandon replied on Doyle's behalf, saying the letters amounted to hype and hyperbole. The real issues are whether the state can afford the program, it's structured in a responsible way and taxpayers get a maximum value, he said.
Hype and hyperbole ... Brandon may have been speaking on background here, but reporters don't just drop poll-tested catch phrases like that into their stories without some prompting.

Brandon, who's title is really awkward, has apparently won the honor of killing the film tax credits ... or at least being the public face of Governor Doyle's desire to do so. He's been in the press a lot lately and usually as the voice of opposition when it comes to the tax credits. Here's my personal favorite, from a story that ran in a number of Gannett papers about a week before Doyle initially proposed ending the program:
MADISON — Wisconsin taxpayers contributed $450,000 toward Hollywood director Michael Mann's salary when he came to the state last year to film the big-budget Johnny Depp movie "Public Enemies."

Records obtained by The Associated Press show the state's film tax credits not only covered a quarter of Mann's $1.8 million salary, they paid for a portion of his assistants' salaries, entertainment, meals and stuntmen's living expenses.

The state's tax credits even covered about $100,000 of the cost of Depp's entourage of chauffeurs, hair stylists and assistants, said Zach Brandon, executive assistant at the Wisconsin Commerce Department.

My favorite part of those three grafs is the word "acquired," as if the records just fell out of the sky and, my, what a coincidence! There just happens to be this appointed official from the Commerce Department right here ready and authorized to comment on the matter. And, wouldn't you know it, but it happens to be the same guy who was hating on the credits two months earlier and will turn out to be the consistent voice of opposition to the credits in just about every succeeding article on the issue that will run in the state for the next month! What marvelous fortune!

In case anyone didn't pick up on the subtext above, I'm insinuating that Commerce gave the report to the AP to foment populist sentiment against the tax credits. Only insinuating, mind you. Not outright saying. To outright say anything, I would need evidence, which I don't have.

Far be it for me to ascribe any nefarious motives to Brandon -- who is pretty clearly taking one for the team here by being the barer of bad news to the public -- but the fact that the Wisconsin "Commerce Department executive assistant" is the point man on this issue means the tax credits as we know them today are as good as dead. The credits have bipartisan support and are pretty popular (at least anecdotaly, I don't think there's been any polling on the issue). Even if Mark Pocan is able to revive them, they are as good as buried under the ink of Doyle's veto pen. Sure, Doyle may actually be the guy who does the killing, but there's no reason he has to be the face of the execution. So he gives that job to a guy with a really long title to further distance himself from the act.

And that sucks for so many reasons.

The first is that the credits are not losing the state any money. Regardless of how the numbers are spun there's just no way of saying this program is in the red. The lowest numbers that have come out on the economic impact of "Public Enemies" are, not surprisingly, from the Commerce Department. They estimate that the film created $5 million in economic activity while being made here in Wisconsin and received $4.6 million in tax credits. Lets look at those numbers for just a moment. Here's the AP summarizing the law:
Under the film incentives law, a production company qualifies for a tax credit of 25 percent of the wages paid to employees to produce a film, video, electronic game, broadcast advertisement, or television program in the state. Credits for sales tax, construction, wardrobes, clothing and visual effects also are included in the law.
So by that measure, $4.6 million is actually 25% of the total the film company spent here in Wisconsin, which means that company spent an additional $13.8 million on production-related costs here in Wisconsin that they did not receive a tax credit for. What this $5 million dollar figure represents has never fully been explained by any press accounts. The law says production companies get 25% back, not 94% back. If the Commerce Department did end up reimbursing the film almost 1:1, then it's a massive fail on their part.

I can only assume the $5 million figure is economic activity that was created around the production from out-of-towners who took the day off to go watch a movie being made and maybe bought a soda and a hot dog from a vendor on the corner -- something like that. If that's the case, then the actual monetary contribution by the film to the state is $13.8 million + $5 million = $18.8 million. And that's before we even start adding in things like the value of publicity from the films and future production deals.

Making matters worse is how disparate the numbers from the Commerce Department seem to be with figures generated by local business bureaus. We've mentioned before here that locally, "Public Enemies" generated an estimated $4 million dollars just here in Oshkosh, which almost covers the Commerce Department's total. If the production company spent money elsewhere like they did here, then the sum economic activity for the state is going to be much greater than what Commerce is copping to.

So the numbers coming out of Commerce don't seem to be all that trustworthy. Either they've intentionally lowballed the figure for whatever reason or they were grossly incompetent in reimbursing the film. Commerce needs to explain how they arrived at there numbers or explain how the film got it's hands on $3.35 million dollars it wasn't supposed to. (Quick math interlude: 25% of $5 million in total economic impact = $1.25 million. $4.6 million in tax credits distributed - $1.25 million = $3.35 million.)

If all of these numbers make little sense to you, I'm just as lost. If there's anyone out there that can tell me what I'm missing/getting wrong, by all means set me straight in the comments. The larger issue, however, is that whatever way Commerce's numbers are manipulated, they never seem to add up correctly. Either Commerce screwed up royally by giving "Public Enemies" way too much money or they are grossly underestimating the actual financial impact of the film on the state.

But let's put aside for a moment the fact that Commerce's numbers are dodgy at best and actually use them. Here's Brandon taking out the trash in the Journal Sentinel:
Zach Brandon, executive assistant for the department, said the state calculated the economic impact of "Public Enemies" in terms of dollars that landed in the hands of local businesses. Even if taxpayers accept Film Wisconsin's figure, the program still provided "a horrible return on investment," Brandon said.
By Commerce's own reckoning, the state put up $4.6 million and got $5 million in return. That means the "horrible return on investment" Brandon is talking about is actually a net gain of $400,000 or roughly 8.7%. For one film. In the first year of the program. There are tons of small business owners who would kill to make any kind of profit their first year in business, to say nothing of almost 9% on their initial investment. Making matters worse is that Brandon is completely ignoring the potential for growth and continued returns on the state's investment from future productions.

But let's take Brandon's advice and use Film Wisconsin's figures of $7.4 million. That means the $2.8 million dollars got pumped back into the economy ... that's a 60+% profit in just a year from one single movie. That's a "horrible return"?

And that's what's so frustrating about this whole charade: Commerce's numbers are so questionable and it's arguments for augmenting the program are so objectionable that they could just as easily be turned around to advocate that the film tax credits are a huge success with limitless potential. Instead, the Governor is taking the other tack.

Why? I don't know for sure, but I have two guesses.

The first reason is bureaucratic. Of the eight films that received credits in Wisconsin last year "Public Enemies" was far and away the highest profile with the highest budget and yet it was the only film that the Commerce Department claims received a 1:1 reimbursement. Here's just a quick look at ahow a few of the smaller films fared:
The Appleton native has already completed on project under the existing tax credit program. Her $750,000 psychological thriller called "Project Solitude" is due out in the fall. The film was shot in Green Bay in December and received about $120,000 in state tax incentives, she said.
That means "Project Solitude" recouped about 16% of it's budget from the state.
"Nephilim," a science fiction thriller based on a comic book about a priest and a detective searching for fallen angels during the end of the world was to shoot for about five weeks in Milwaukee and Green Bay starting in May, she said. It was slated to get about $750,000 in tax breaks, Moses said.
We've noted earlier that "Nephilim" has a budget of about $6 million, which means it would be getting 12.5% back from the state.

So how in God's name did "Public Enemies" get back 94% of it's costs from the Commerce Department (again, this is using the Dept.'s own disputed numbers here)?

My guess is that the accountants and financiers of "Public Enemies" have done this before; in fact, they do it for a living and simply ran circles around the Commerce Department who has little experience, if any, auditing films. If a film can assemble A-list talent in front of the camera and behind it, I'm going to guess that they can get some ninja accountants with black belts in expenditure voodoo as well. Instead of looking at the reimbursement request carefully, they cut a check before they could say "What was that for, again?" If Commerce doesn't seem capable of presenting the public with numbers that make sense now, what are the chances that they were able to use them correctly back when it came time to pay the piper?

Instead of admitting that there's going to be something of a learning curve to these credits, Commerce is covering itself during a time when the state has a $5 billion budget deficit by holding "Public Enemies" up and saying "All films are going to be like this, so it's just not worth it."

Again, that's just speculation based on what's available in the public record. I sincerely hope this is not the case.

The second reason is political. Sticking it to those rich fat cats in Wall Street/Washington/Hollywood seems to be all the rage these days -- and there's no one better for politicians to pick on than folks who don't vote here. That makes the "Public Enemies" producers easy targets. I'm worried that this might be a classic example of someone seeing an angry mob roaming the streets and saying to himself "I must follow them, for surely they will need a leader!"

Doyle's probably running for re-election next year and you can probably bet the house that a phrase you're going to hear over and over again is "$5 billion budget deficit." (Hell, it might even be $6 billion by then.) So now would probably be a good time to start flexing some fiscal muscles. While not exactly loved by the Left, Doyle's got some capital to burn and this is a convenient way of riding the current wave of populism in an attempt to poach moderate voters. I have to admit, from a political perspective, it's not a dumb idea.

Again, this is all just idle speculation.

The Governor's handled the tax credits issue just like a politician. He's set the credits' death to a slow burn and got a proxy to do the dirty work. The problem is that it's not necessary. Barring some calamity, Doyle will probably win re-election handily.

Doyle is at his best when he takes the long view, like with his biotech proposal. A vibrant film industry in Wisconsin will not just provide folks with a few hours of entertainment, but will help change the image of the state (more so than any fancy new logo will ever do). There is a solid and sound economic argument for continuing the tax credits. There is an even better argument for keeping the credits for the next few years just to see what happens, and it would be a shame to see a fledgling industry with a lot of potential strangled in its crib for the sake of scoring a few cheap populist points.

Regardless of its motives, it's clear that the Doyle Administration wants nothing to do with these tax credits. I imagine there's some urgency to kill the tax credits before "Public Enemies" is released on July 1st. If the movie is released and is a huge hit (and there's some indication that might be the case), it's going to be harder to get rid of them -- and let's face it, the alternative offered in the budget will effectively do just that. I just hope that when they do go we don't see someone from the Doyle Administration standing in front of a movie theater praising all the hard work that folks from Wisconsin did to make this movie happen.

Monday, March 23, 2009

School Choice, Change and Taxes

Aaron Rodriguez has an odd admission in the place usually reserved for the thesis statement of most essays in his post on school choice today:
Fernandez, an agent of change, comes from a tradition of being “outside” the education bureaucracy. And if there is anything that November has taught America, it's that a bold reformist candidate can allure a frustrated and embittered people into voting for change. With 30 years of failed MPS policies and wasteful spending, Rose Fernandez's message of "shaking things up" is gaining momentum and starting to draw attention in the Milwaukee area.

(emphasis added)
The problem with this argument is that for the last 20 years or so the status quo in Milwaukee Public Schools has been "school choice," or, to speak more specifically, a variety of school choice that has by the admission of the very people who long advocated for it underwhelmed.

Here's a recent article from the American, the online magazine of the American Enterprise Institute, an organization that can hardly be accused of being held in the thrall of teachers unions:
Even staunch proponents of school choice are conceding disappointment. Earlier this year, Weekly Standard contributor Daniel Casse reported, “The two most recent studies show that, since the implementation of the voucher program, reading scores across all Milwaukee schools are falling.” Howard Fuller, patron saint of the voucher program, has wryly acknowledged, “I think that any honest assessment would have to say that there hasn’t been the deep, wholesale improvement in MPS [Milwaukee Public Schools] that we would have thought.” Manhattan Institute scholar Sol Stern, one-time choice enthusiast and author of Breaking Free: Public School Lessons and the Imperative of School Choice, brought the concerns to a boiling point earlier this year when he declared, “Fifteen years into the most expansive school choice program tried in any urban school district [there is] . . . no ‘Milwaukee miracle,’ no transformation of the public schools has taken place.”
In fact, far from being an "agent of change," when it comes to school choice Fernandez wants expand the current program, the very one long time proponents are now saying has not worked. Here's a policy statement from her website:
The school choice program works. Thousands of Milwaukee families have benefited from this voucher program over the years. The choice program was not intended to replace MPS or to turn our attention away from fixing its many problems. It was designed to give parents the choice afforded wealthier individuals who can move to areas with better public schools. I was pleased to see the legislature raise the cap on participation in the program a few years ago, but I’d like to see the cap removed altogether.

(emphasis added)
Expanding the program means higher taxes. There's no other way around it. The voucher program now costs over $100 million, yet there's no word on Fernandez's web site as to where the money for a program increase is going to come from. One would imagine it might not be from the federal stimulus money, since Fernandez has apparently not decided on whether she will use it or not yet.

I digress, but only slightly. Throwing more money at a problem isn't going to solve it, right? That's what teachers unions want -- more money to build more schools and put more teachers on the public dime (all of which has the effect of making WEAC more powerful, of course). That used to be popular argument given by conservatives who used to scoff at giving more money to failing school districts. And they had a point, only now they're using that exact same argument to defend a program that's done little because they want to expand it.

But expansion is part of, if not the most significant part of, the problem. Again, from the American:
Milwaukee illustrates the uneven quality of new providers and reminds us that high performing schools are (like so many nonprofits) ill-equipped to expand in response to demand. Indeed, it has taken the celebrated KIPP schools—operated by an organization lauded for its aggressive expansion—14 years to grow to 65 schools enrolling 16,000 students in a nation where 95,000 K–12 district schools enroll 50 million students. Even today, the national KIPP network serves just one-sixth as many students as the Milwaukee public school system. The struggle to find capital and talent, overcome regulatory obstacles, and maintain quality has forced even growth-minded KIPP to move at a pace that would be considered maddeningly slow in almost any other sector (14 years, after all, was more than enough time for ventures like Google, Microsoft, and Amazon to grow from boutique firms to omnipresent brands serving millions of customers).

Personally, I think its inherently absurd to compare the progress of a middle school -- any middle school -- with Google, but since much of the intellectual heavy lifting for the voucher program was done on a "free market" weight machine, such is the gymnasium the "school choice" movement selected as its home court: if the choice movement wants to be serious about setting high standards for schools, both public and private, they first have to adhere to their own.

And that hasn't happened. Here's a more "liberal" slant on "school choice:"
For a long time, it was absurdly difficult to find out whether this was true in the one place where vouchers had been tried over an extended period: Milwaukee. After that city's initial small-scale initiative produced ambiguous, but generally unimpressive, results (and a lot of fighting over that data), the Wisconsin legislature chose to omit testing requirements altogether when the program was significantly expanded in 1998. This February, however, a group of researchers led by professors Patrick J. Wolf and John F. Witte produced the first installment of a study intended to follow how comparable groups of students in the public and private voucher schools perform over time. At least at the outset, they found no statistically significant differences in the test scores between the public and private school fourth and eighth graders for the 2006-07 school year. For the private as well as the public school students, the scores generally hovered around the 33rd percentile—in other words, a typically low performance for schools with high concentrations of poverty.
The bottom line: we were promised transformation and the choice program has been a wash, and by those standards it's failed. That's the actual reason for the "liberal" opposition to the program -- it just hasn't worked. If it had, educators, administrators and think tankers would be crawling out of the wood work to sing its praises, but it turns out institutional education is a difficult thing to master and an even harder thing to replicate when it's created out of the blue.

There are a lot of struggling inner city school systems around the country and the argument can be put forth that an obstacle to those school systems succeeding has been the reluctance of teachers and administrators to experiment with much more than asking communities for more money. Not Milwaukee. Milwaukee's one of the few places where school choice advocates have gotten their way. They've had their way for almost two decades now and have little to show for it. Fernandez may be the "outsider" candidate running to administer the DPI, but she's certainly not planning on changing anything when it comes to a program that has, by the very admission of the people who so passionately fought for it, underperformed.

Saturday, March 7, 2009

Arlen Specter: Screw You Guys, I'm Going Home?

Courtesy of El Rushbo, no less:
Specter can blame Operation Chaos for that development. In 2008, over 150,000 Pennsylvania Republicans switched to the Democratic primary to vote for Hillary Clinton over Barack Obama. Most of those were centrists and moderates, and most of them haven’t switched back. If they stay out, they won’t be able to participate in the closed Pennsylvania primaries in 2010. Specter’s close shave in 2004 would almost certainly transform into a lopsided defeat under those circumstances, especially with his vote on Porkulus.
Here's Specter slaying at the Improv:



MORE: Just to be a bit clearer, I'm being a bit facetious by attributing the mass defections of Penn Republicans to Limbaugh. If they left to register as Dems for the 2007 presidential primary and are staying Dems today, then they probably were moderates -- not exactly the kind of people listen to Rush, to say nothing of doing what he says.

Saturday, February 14, 2009

Thursday, February 5, 2009

Kevin Fischer, Sock Puppets and Ghostwriters

Here's an interesting confession from one half of Wisconsin's worst legislative team:


Here's the text, just in case the captures renders the print too small to read:
It's a huge pet peeve of mine. In an ideal world, everyone who writes or comments on the Internet would have to divulge his/her true identity. Not all but far too many that choose to use a false identity or nickname have an ulterior motive at hand.

These cowards hide behind a false name to pump themselves up in their feeble minds, cause mischief, be mean or cruel, or at worst, commit crimes.
So how does that jive with Fischer ghostwriting some of his boss' posts on her blog?

Wednesday, February 4, 2009

Dream Team

But we already knew that:

Worst Legislator and Legislative Aide

Garnering the third-most votes for worst legislator was Sen. Mary Lazich (R-New Berlin). “Literally nuts,” pronounced one GOP activist. “There may be no legislator taken less seriously.”

That rating becomes all the more interesting when you consider that Lazich’s aide is Kevin Fischer, an outspoken windbag who does a blog on FranklinNOW.com, has guest hosted on WISN-AM 1130 and is a regular pundit for Milwaukee Public Television’s InterChange program.

Fischer’s grating style has even annoyed some of his fellow conservatives. Fairly Conservative blogger Cindy Kilkenny calls Fischer a bully. As Milwaukee Magazine Pressroom columnist Erik Gunn has written, Kilkenny has been on a campaign to prove Fischer has been working on his blog on state time. She hasn’t gotten the public records she requested from Lazich’s office and is now threatening to contact the attorney general.

Lazich told Milwaukee Magazine she doesn’t tolerate “nastiness” from her staff, but Fischer said Lazich has never counseled him to tone down his often intemperate style.

All told, there may be no combination of legislator and legislative aide who are taken less seriously in the capitol than Mary Lazich and Kevin Fischer. They work together for a reason.

(emphasis added)

McCain-Feingold II?

Russ Feingold's proposed constitutional amendment to end gubernatorial appointments to the senate is co-sponsored by none other than John McCain.

Maybe Feingold can get top billing this time?

Thursday, January 29, 2009

Things to do in Tampa When You're Dead

Behold, civic priorities!
[T]here are a total of 43 strip clubs in Tampa. That’s more than the city’s hospitals (12), high schools (41), fire stations (21) or synagogues (13). The only place that rivals the clubs is McDonald’s, which also comes in at 43.