Showing posts with label Paul Esslinger. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Paul Esslinger. Show all posts

Friday, April 20, 2012

Don't Call it a Comeback (No, Seriously, Please Don't)

So the big local news this afternoon is that Paul Esslinger will be running for state assembly.

Esslinger spent eleven years on the city council, the last two as mayor, and during that time he provided voters with countless examples of just how uniquely unqualified he is to conduct public affairs. Here are just a few examples from his disastrous first year as mayor. The only real aspiration, plan or vision for the city he ever stated publicly was the creation of a Bay Beach-like amusement park at Menominee Park. His only accomplishment of note was his small role in the renovation of Pollock Pool.

More often than not Esslinger used his office to air personal grievances. He will campaign as a small government conservative on a mission to cut spending, but this is the same guy who demanded the city pay his legal bills when he got into a scuffle, and was subsequently investigated by the DOJ, with a fellow council member. He pretty much demanded the city pay for the fire truck he bought as a "donation." Then there was the Great Sidewalk Debate of 2007 in which Esslinger basically forced the residents of a subdivision in Oshkosh to install sidewalks in their neighborhood and pay for it too. We could go on, but suffice it to say that ideological consistency usually plays second fiddle to his own sense of entitlement. Here are a couple examples: 1.) Esslinger changed his tune on various "pub fees" once he started running his own tavern. 2.) At the around the same time, Esslinger flip-flopped on a proposed downtown parking lot from which several competing pubs down the street from his own establishment stood to benefit. These are indicative someone who lacks the ability to thinks about the ramifications of his actions beyond himself.

Esslinger has a habit of even screwing up good-natured gestures, like the time he gave his friend and council member Dennis McHugh an envelope full of cash as a "retirement gift" during a council meeting and provided a very poor explanation as to why. Even McHugh looked a bit uncomfortable accepting the gift at the time. This wasn't just an instance of Esslinger being very oblivious. The cash was the leftover money collected by McHugh's friends to pay for a full-page ad in the local paper thanking McHugh for his years of service. There are very serious and legitimate questions as to the legality of the gift. There was no question that the whole episode looked sketchy.

He has a habit of watching opportunities to provide leadership pass him by. At times he's misused his office for political purposes. He has an inability to choose his battles. His relationship with the local media is abysmal. He has a habit of executing political duties vindictively and without class.

But Esslinger's most troubling quality is his almost pathological craving for acceptance. It's his defining characteristic. Rarely did a meeting go by during the decade he was on the council when Esslinger did not give a speech or cast a vote that appeared to beg for the approval of his friend and political mentor Dennis McHugh. People with business before knew that the quickest way to win Esslinger's support was to flatter, stroke his ego and, above all else, make him feel important. A lot politicians suffer from this desire, and in some this appetite for validation can be an asset that motivates them to do big things. But in others, and Esslinger definitely falls into this camp, it's a liability that leaves them susceptible to manipulation from folks like lobbyists and party leaders.

McHugh retired at the end of Esslinger's first year as mayor and in the second half of his only term Esslinger actually showed signs of maturity. There were far fewer distractions, much less grandstanding, and actual moments of genuine reflection and courage. Take, for example, his vote to approve a use permit for Oshkosh's first mosque. Even though the council meeting at which the vote took place was packed with very vocal supporters of the measure, it's hard to image those who did not voicing their opinions to any other council member. A lot of people attribute this evolution to Esslinger becoming a small business owner, and that may have certainly had a lot to do with it, but don't underestimate the impact McHugh's absence had on someone who is so impressionable. (Just to be clear: I'm not necessarily suggesting McHugh wouldn't have supported the mosque permit had he been on the council at the time. It's just a rare example of Esslinger not giving in to some of the more lamentable instincts of his base.)  

Instead of continuing his evolution after leaving office, Esslinger went back to the Well of Bad Influences when he teamed up with his friend Ben Schneider to create Oshkosh Area Politics, their execrable public access TV show. The conversations on OAP offer little insight except into the minds of two recovering politicians who were marginalized to the point of impotence and now blame everyone but themselves for their own failures in office.

Schneider now serves as McHugh's surrogate. It's not a step in the right direction. McHugh was more of a curmudgeon than an ideologically driven conservative, and not without his charm (recall the touching story he told about visiting the Grand Opera House with his wife before vote to authorize renovation funds). Schneider treats anyone who is not in perfect lockstep with him ideologically with condescension and derision. His inability to work with people he disagrees with is the stuff of local legend. Watching Esslinger and Schneider work themselves into a Berserker rage frenzy on OAP it's easy to see just how much of Schneider is rubbing off on Esslinger.

Needless to say, Paul Esslinger is the last thing Madison needs right now.

Tuesday, May 4, 2010

City Manager Evaluations

Yesterday the city council evaluations of City Manager Mark Rohloff were published by the NW. We've got the PDF below if you're interested -- page 4 is where all the action's at.

Rohloff was graded primarily on averages of each individual city councilor's assessment, as the NW dutifully pointed out. But we decided to break apart the averages and see what kind of score's each specific council member gave Rohloff.

Here's how we went about it: In each category Rohloff was eligible for a high score of 7 and a low score of 1 -- no zeros were to be awarded. Since there were five groups with five different evaluations, a perfect score would be 175. Let's stress here's that there's almost no chance that anyone would ever get anything that approached a perfect score from any of the council members. It would look politically odd. This isn't going to be like a test anyone took in school, where 90% and above equals an A, etc. It's far more complicated than that.

On the other hand, the lowest score Rohloff could have scored was 35. We're just going to assume for the sake of convenience that because Rohloff couldn't score a zero on any of his evaluations, that this helps to compensate for the fact that he has no chance of hitting the bulls eye.

Here's what each individual councilor gave Rohloff:
Harold Bucholtz: 140/175 = 80%
Jess King: 136.5/175 = 77.4%
Burk Tower: 122/175 = 69.7%
Bob Poeschl = 114/175 = 65.1%
Paul Esslinger = 111/175 = 63.4%
Dennis McHugh = 101/175 = 57.7%
Tony Palmeri = 83/175 = 47.4%
Now for the obligatory disclaimer: The math here might be off by a little since the initial arithmetic was pretty much all eye-balled. Someone else should really double check the work here.
Oshkosh City Manager Evaluation 2010

Monday, April 19, 2010

Help Us Figure Out How Mayor Esslinger Will Screw Up Next

Can somebody please explain to me why an envelope full of cash was given by the Mayor to a retiring councilman in the city council chamber last Tuesday?

I actually went back to look at the footage and I still don't know what the money was for -- it's never really made clear by anyone involved just what the hell was going on. The only explanation that Esslinger bothers to give are the words "fund-raising," "money" and "advertising." When I first heard them I thought he was talking about political campaign money, but EoO says otherwise:
Paul Esslinger apparently did some fundraising and, I have heard, bought some advertising to honor Mr. McHugh.
This makes much more sense: Esslinger raised money to take out a full-page ad, which aren't cheap, thanking McHugh for his years of service. He then framed the ad and presented it to McHugh on his last day at the office and gave him the money left over from the fund-raising effort. In an envelope. In front of everyone at the council meeting. Live on TV.

All this looked extremely sketchy, especially given the fact that McHugh was the one who formally proposed the tavern fee rescission that put Esslinger into a conflict of interest and then was the only council member to vote for the proposition.

Anyway, absolutely none of that was made clear at the meeting. I gather that the ad ran prior to the meeting and that Esslinger assumed that everyone in town saw and knew the back story behind it, but that was obviously not the case. A little explanation would have gone a long way toward making a nice gesture seem less, you know, dubious.

What will Mayor Esslinger Screw up Next?
Ignore an obvious conflict of interest
Dubious fund-raising scheme
Flippant remark from the council dais
Another bar fight
Ill-advised use of mayoral authority
pollcode.com free polls

Saturday, April 10, 2010

The City Council, Post-Election

We promised a look at the new city council earlier in the week ... so here you go:

Like the school board, the city council underwent a sharp shift on Tuesday. Dennis McHugh was a reliably populist conservative and Harold Bucholtz, alas, was not around long enough to pigeon-hole into any kind of ideological operating style. Taking their places will be two people -- Steve Cummings and Steven Herman -- who look very similar to the only incumbent to win re-election, Burk Tower. Or as the NW says:
It would be easy to portray the re-election of Burk Tower and the election of Steve Herman and Steve Cummings as a victory for the Oshkosh Chamber of Commerce. All three ran as pro-development candidates and the two newcomers enjoyed the backing of the chamber and business interests.

But the messages of the winners, in an election that had no real hot button issues, were not all that different from those of the also-rans. All of the candidates focused on planning, economic development and continuing to improve communication between City Hall and the community.
That seems fair enough, to an extent; but here's where the NW starts to veer off the target:
The fact that the election focused on such big-picture issues shows that the city has been successful in beginning to address issues that were a long-standing source of voter angst: crumbling infrastructure and poor customer service.

That allowed the winners of Tuesday's election to run campaigns that were underscored by a theme of returning the council to its proper role of setting direction for city staff and staying out of the minutia of day to day decision making and policy implementation.
That's actually the opposite take-away I got from Tuesday's election. I'd say that after a year of being constantly side-tracked by a pair of council members, voters wanted a council that was more interested in making the trains run on time than worrying about philosophical questions like Is killing deer murder? and Who skipped over Journey on the jukebox? To put it politely, Tower, Cummings and Herman were the three least eccentric candidates on the ballot.

Paradoxically, those boring candidates now make next year's election much more interesting on account of the council's three most eccentric candidates being up for re-election. If this year is the start of a trend, then Oshkosh is looking for competent technocrats who get the job done without much fuss. If a set of clam, low-key and level-headed candidates emerge to challenge next year's incumbents they could change the temperament of the council for some time to come.

Next year also becomes interesting for purely arithmetical reasons. Paul Eslinger can not win another term as Mayor. Period. If a ham sandwich runs against him, it will win. But there is always a chance he can rally enough support on the South Side to continue to serve on the council. That would presumably create a situation where 4 incumbents are vying for 3 at-large seats while the Mayoral chair is open. Who knows: maybe Esslinger and another council member will duke it out for the Mayor's Sash? There are many permutations that could take place next spring, all of which are contingent on a countless string of variables (will voters vote for both Palmeri and Poeschl, or just one or the other? etc.) and many of them result in yet another shift in the council's composition.

Sunday, March 28, 2010

Paul Esslinger's Greatest Hits

Shortly after Paul Esslinger was elected Mayor last year we predicted bad things:
After nine years on the city council Essingler has nothing to show for his tenure except a string of polarizing incidents that do little in terms of moving the city forward, but are a great way of getting one's name in the paper.
Of course, Esslinger has extended that practice to his tenure as Mayor. Here are some of Esslinger's greatest hits almost a year after being elected:
Although Councilman Bucholtz has turned out to be a dedicated public servant and something of a breath of fresh air on the council, the whole process was a belabored mess and not exactly a confidence-building exercise.
What he should have done was express his intentions to both Bowen and Maddox and seek their input on possible successors. Then when the time came to make the changes public, he should have released a statement thanking the two of them for their service. I'm not suggesting Esslinger give them the keys to the City, but a "thank you" was the very least he could have done ... and I mean the absolute minimum.
To Esslinger's credit, he did manage to pull an event together, but only after considerable hand-wringing during what was essentially a "no confidence" vote by the traditional sponsors of the event.
A flip-flop on a project shortly after Esslinger bought out the ownership of Screwballs bar. Left unsaid was the positive effect that project was going to have a several competing taverns downtown and if that was a factor in his decision to oppose the project.
The Deer Cull really wasn't so much about what Esslinger did do so much as he what he didn't do. Instead of providing much leadership on the matter, he actually went to Governor Doyle to see what he could about it:
There's absolutely no need for another committee to essentially resolve a single animal control issue and it's ridiculous that Esslinger has to waste political capital by meeting with the Governor over this issue. (I don't care who is in the office, but the Governor of Wisconsin has far more important things to worry about that a whether the City of Oshkosh can take control a few dozen deer.)
If there's one incident that embodies the Esslinger management style, it's this one. The sad thing is that this is the kind of project that, with a little forethought and advance notice, could have been net positive to the city. Arranging a price with the seller and asking him to put the truck on hold would have made raising private funds easier (even in this economy). Now no one's sure if the money's going to Esslinger, the city, the fire department, the seller... It's a bloody mess, it never had to be and it will likely be the thing most voters remember when they enter the voting booth next spring.
Pretty much an embarrassment to everyone in the city.
Ongoing ...

If we've missed any, feel free to jog our memories in the comments section below. In the past we've referred to ordeals such as the above as "distractions" -- nothing really corrupt or criminal, just the product of incredibly poor decision-making. The problem with these distractions is that they have a tendency to occupy the time and energy of a city council that could be working on other things. For example, we have been talking about buying an antique fire truck since early November of last year. Six months is a long time to worry about a fire truck that's not actually going to be putting out any fires.

But if you look at the way these distractions have unfolded -- they are listed above in chronological order -- a pattern starts to emerge. The first few were acts of thoughtlessness on his part, or political calculations that were made without regard to the optics. The more recent incidents, however, have veered into "conflict of interest" territory and appear to be evidence of a sense of entitlement that points down a trajectory that should worry the city.

When he ran for Mayor, Esslinger said he wanted his office to concentrate on four issues: public safety, sewage treatment, jobs and infrastructure. Instead, he's mostly devoted his attention to jukeboxes and firetrucks. God only knows what's next.

Mayor Esslinger: Working for Himself

No surprise here:
Records obtained by The Northwestern show the mayor approved many of the fees that could be repealed. Esslinger voted to increase live music/jukebox fee, mechanical devices fee and the limited service restaurant inspection fee during meetings in 2003 and 2006 while a member of the council.

Esslinger said his experience owning Screwballs since last summer has changed his perspective on fees businesses have to pay.

[...]

Oshkosh Tavern League President Pat Purtell said his organization did not lobby for the changes, but welcomes rolling back any fees on its members. He said Esslinger had complained to him shortly after he purchased Screwballs last summer about the fees.
Some of these fees seem a bit over the top. Others, like the $20 per electronic gambling machine could be increased, since those things make a goddamn killing.

The real problem I have with this story is that it's a perfect example of how Esslinger operates. The only times he ever seems to want to do something is when he sees something that effects his everyday life. As a result, the city might lose up to $50,000 a year in revenue and might also have to fork $15,000 (this year) for an antique fire engine it will get basically railroaded into buying.

And for what reason? Because Esslinger doesn't want to pay $360 in fees? We don't know if we should all be astonished by just how transparently self-interested this move is or amazed at how petty.

Thursday, December 3, 2009

Sunday, June 7, 2009

Ink Blots

We had planned an elaborate post on the Mayor's Breakfast to-do, but since there will be no event this year -- much of what we were going to say is, alas, immaterial.

But that's not going to stop us from making one relevant observation. We were a bit surprised by the ferocity of the conversation regarding the Breakfast (both online and off) and are worried about what it portends. Frankly, we see the day soon approaching wherein any type of local event, positive or negative, immediately becomes a kind of Rorschach test over Esslinger's leadership.

And we mean even the events that don't even remotely involve him.

Saturday, June 6, 2009

Mayor's Breakfast to Move to a Single Booth at the Perkins on Highway 41

We have a pretty good feeling that the Mayor's Breakfast shitshow just now getting under way won't end until well after whatever event comes to replace it. In the mean time there we can all sit back and enjoy finger-pointing, name-calling, gnashing of teeth and rending of hair. We'll have more to say on the matter in the next few days (and there is plenty to say).

For now, we'll just note that this is the fourth divisive distraction to befall the civic conversation in the six weeks of Esslinger's reign (Appointmentgate, L'Affaire Buchholtz & the ongoing Parking Lot Debacle).

Wednesday, June 3, 2009

For It Before He was Against It!

How the hell does this make sense?
Esslinger has opposed the parking lot since fall, when it was included in the city’s annual capital improvements program. He argues it is a luxury the city cannot afford in light of pressing needs to upgrade sewers and other infrastructure.

Still, he and McHugh voted in favor of borrowing $972,000 for the project in late April. Esslinger said he signed off on the bond issue on the assumption that he’d have one more chance to kill the project. That opportunity will come up when construction easements and bids for the work go to the council this summer for approval.

"I was under the understanding from our city staff we would have one more kick at the cat," Esslinger said. "I think the staff needs to be more clear to the council when these issues come up. We need to be told ‘This is it. You need to vote no here.’ Or they need to explain exactly what the vote means."
But if you don't like it, why not just vote no when it's in front of you?

By the way, an animal abuse metaphor is just plain creepy.

MORE: From "logichead" (a misnomer if ever there was one):
Good for you , Paul....stick to your guns and listen to the majority of voters. Downtown is dead. Don't spend more of our tax dollars on it. Also....can the Grand. It's a old pile of bricks that needs to go, It wil be less expensive to build a new theatre that to repair the old junk pile.

(emphasis added)
Esslinger is flip-flopping and this putz is telling him to "stick to your guns" ... what guns are those?

That's right, the guy also said "screw the Grand" ...

Wednesday, May 20, 2009

Paul Esslinger Controls the Media (Part 3)

There appears to be no end to the number of constituents Paul Esslinger is trying to aggravate during his brief time in office. This far he has taken swipes at friends and supporters of Shirley Maddox and Karen Bowen and seems now dead set on pissing off downtown business owners.

Eventually, Esslinger is going to have to bring people to the table instead of just alienating them. He could get away with these kinds of stunts if he were just another member of the council where you can win a seat with around 30% of the total vote, but once he starts developing the reputation as being impulsively divisive, it's over.

Paul Esslinger Controls the Media (Part 2)

God help us all, but seven individuals have applied to fill the empty council seat and there appears to be two clear favorites: Steve Cummings and Larry Spanbauer.

We've noted before that Steve Cummings was probably not going to win over a majority of the Council fresh off the election, but now that he's positioned himself next to a few other applicants he probably has a better shot.

But now there's a intriguing detail thrown into the mix. Tacked onto the end of Spanbauer's application is a letter of recommendation from none other than Paul Esslinger ... seriously!

Spanbauer's served on the council before, so he can not exactly be accused of bringing a fresh voice to the council, but to flagrantly pander to a wing of the council in such a blatant way is really astonishing. Spanbauer's resume looks impressive by itself --the inclusion of Esslinger's letter essentially negates all of Spanbauer's previously mentioned qualifications and says through a Cheshire grin, "Yeah, here's how I'll vote!" Why in God's name would you make an appointment any more political than it already is?

If for no other reason than this silly mistake, appointing Spanbauer back to the council should be given a second thought. Unless more candidates submit their applications, get ready for the council to split into three minds over the appointment: two seats will favor Cummings, two seats will go for Spanbauer, and two seats will eventually make the call.

Paul Esslinger Controls the Media (Part 1)

There is no shortage of Esslinger-related news today and rather than just deluge readers with it in one big post I'm going to stagger over several. So without further ado...

Up first is the UW-O city services survey.

Now, before we get all excited about this survey vindicating certain opinions we may or may not have (a-hem...), let's take this thing with a grain of salt. There are numerous reasons to doubt that this is an accurate representation to the city. The number of returned surveys seems rather small and judging by the popularity of the Senior Center, I would gather that the respondent pool also skews a little on the older side. The questions leave much to be desired for as well, as they seem a bit nebulous.

So we should be right on board any paragraph that starts off: "Mayor Paul Esslinger said other parts of the survey seemed inconclusive," right? And we were ... but then we read the rest of it:
In particular, the survey noted that the majority of recipients either had no opinion on the Pollock Aquatic Center or gave it low marks. The survey also found that 78 percent of recipients did not have children.

"I don't know how to take that," he said.

Huh?

Of all the things that could be said about the survey the only thing the mayor could think of commenting on was the swimming pool?

Monday, May 18, 2009

Spare Us with the Term Limits Nonsense

The conversation regarding the replacement of several long-serving city board members by Mayor Esslinger -- at least at the NW forum -- has devolved into a discussion over term limits.

Let's make one thing perfectly clear: talking about term limits is nothing more than a distraction designed to shift the focus of Esslinger's mayoral fail to what some people see as a flaw in the system. Instead of examining the crass and transparently political way in which Esslinger is currently embarrassing himself and the city, his supporters are running around yelling, "It's not Paul, it's the system that's flawed!"

But based on the information available online (which is absurdly difficult to put together, by the way), that's just not true.

Despite making some 42 appointments and reappointments, Esslinger may still have not filled at least 3 seats on various city boards. Those vacancies are on the Board of Appeals (one seat), the Parking Utility Commission (one seat), and at least one seat (maybe two) on the Committee on Aging.

Why aren't these seats being filled first? Why are other people being pushed to the side when there are still empty spots that need to be filled?

The easy answer is that "No one's applied for them," but that's not acceptable in our book. Instead of replacing a pair of board members with considerable experience in city government with two comparatively unseasoned new guys, Esslinger should have filled the empty slots by recruiting for them. There's no reason Monte could not have spent some time on the Board of Zoning Appeals (or another board) before moving to the Plan Commission when a space became available.

Which brings us back to the absurdity of discussing term limits when there are vacancies on municipal boards. Simply put, there is just not the demand to justify putting term limits on boards. If folks are so desperate to serve the city, they should start on a board with openings. It doesn't matter if you are qualified to discuss Parking Utility issues -- you'll learn ... or you won't, and that will speak to your qualifications to sit on another board.

Let's just call this what this is: a shamelessly blatant attempt to remake the municipal board in Esslinger's own image. Screaming all this nonsense about term limits is not going to change that.

Michelle Monte: Not Helping Esslinger's Case Very Much

Michelle Monte jumped into the Appointmentgate fray yesterday offering this gem:
Look at the facts. Check the list of appointments. Check the list of current committee members. Mrs. Mattox is still on a committee where once she was on two. Having one person on multiple committees seems counterproductive to allowing as many as possible serve the community.
We took her advice and noticed that Esslinger actually appointed someone to the Plan Commission -- Robert Vajgrt -- whom he also reappointed to another board (the Police and Fire commission)!

Anyone care to explain that inconsistency?

Sunday, May 17, 2009

Paul Esslinger, Oshkosh's Boss Hogg

Please read the NW's editorial today on Appointmentgate.

We're basically in complete agreement with one tiny exception: Esslinger isn't engaging in "Chicago politics." That's giving him too much credit. He's more like Boss Hogg, a bumbling fool who devotes the majority of his mental energy to concocting absurd schemes that seek to consildate power through minimal effort.

Thursday, May 14, 2009

Paul Esslinger, A Real Class Act

A few points on Paul Esslinger's essential dismissal of Ted Bowen and Shirley Maddox from their respects seats on two city boards ...
  • 1.) It was handled in the completely classless way that we should expect from Esslinger.
Maddox and Bowen have both devoted decades to serving the city in various capacities and essentially fall under the category of local "elder statesmen" -- not "good old boys," mind you, but people who have devoted a great deal of time and energy to making this city a better place. Regardless of what anyone may think of their positions on issues, there is little doubt they arrive at them from a sincere desire to make Oshkosh a better place.

Folks like that are very rare in any city and when the time comes for them to move on they deserve to be honored, or at least thanked, for their service. The article makes it clear that neither of them were ready to move on. Now, as it is the mayor's prerogative to appoint people to various city boards, Esslinger has ever right not to re-appoint Bowen and Maddox, but when one does so to people with long records of service a little decorum is required. Esslinger clearly doesn't understand that.

What he should have done was express his intentions to both Bowen and Maddox and seek their input on possible successors. Then when the time came to make the changes public, he should have released a statement thanking the two of them for their service. I'm not suggesting Esslinger give them the keys to the City, but a "thank you" was the very least he could have done ... and I mean the absolute minimum.

By the way, this "screw you" attitude Esslinger is so fabulously demonstrating is a significant reason why numerous businesses have decided not to set up stakes in Oshkosh. I'm not saying Esslinger is directly responsible for losing businesses, but his classlessness is indicative of an attitude that has permeated local government and cost the city dearly over the years. How we treat ourselves is usually a reflection of how we treat others and there's no incentive for City Hall to change it's ways when the guy in charge lacks any degree of tact whatsoever.
  • 2.) Esslinger's rationale for the move is equally oblivious.
Here's what Hizzoner had to say about his motives:
“I want to see some debate,” Esslinger said. “I want to see some real debate on issues and not just rubber stamps.”
Get used to that phrase, Oshkosh, because you're going to be hearing it a lot. Esslinger could have said "fresh ideas," "new blood," or even "contrarian views." Instead he said "debate," which is to say he just wants people that will argue -- not produce their own ideas or solutions -- just argue. He wants "obstructionists," you could say.

What makes this stranger is that Bowen was actually the last thing from a rubber stamp during his time on the Parks board. In fact, Bowen was arguably the most "conservative" member of the board. I use "conservative" in the old fashioned sense that he was extremely resistant to change. There were a ton of very popular initiatives that Bowen opposed much to the frustration of other members of the board. By Esslinger's own definition Bowen is the kind of person he should want sitting on the board. While not quite the contrarian Bowen was, Maddox always did her due diligence and had valid reasons for voting the way she did. Her famously sunny disposition, enthusiasm and optimism were also a valuable asset in a town that is typically dour and pessimistic when it comes to things like development.

So when Esslinger implies that Bowen and Maddox are "rubber stamps" he's basically saying that they are either too stupid to know how to arrive at decisions on their own or, even worse, are being manipulated by forces unseen. It's a pretty odious insult to levy on a pair that have served the city honorably and selflessly for a long time.
  • 3.) Of course it was politically motivated!
Here's when small town politics starts becoming personal -- more like hand-to-hand combat than an exchange of artillery fire. In fact, it's not so much personal as it is downright incestuous.

Bowen's biggest problem isn't his record of service, which as we noted above would appear to be exactly what Esslinger is looking for. It's his wife, school board member Karen Bowen. In certain quarters of Oshkosh, Mrs. Bowen has the reputation for being a bra-burning feminist commie hellbent on raising your tax dollars to indoctrinate your children with atheism or maybe witchcraft (or something). Those who see her as such, probably voted for Paul Esslinger. Getting rid of Mr. Bowen isn't about losing a "rubber stamp;" it's about sticking it to Mrs. Bowen and her supporters, who -- let's be honest here -- probably did not vote for Paul Esslinger.

There's another complication to all of this. One of Karen Bowen's ideological antitheses on the school board is Michelle Monte, part of a husband/wife team that has tied their political fortunes with Esslinger's for some years now. I'm not suggesting that there was a conspiracy between the Montes and Esslinger to boot Bowen from the parks board (that would take a degree of planning that, frankly, I don't think they're capable of), but I am saying that they are smart enough to realize that what's good for one half of the team is good for the other and that Esslinger, to his Machiavellian credit, seized on an opportunity when he was presented with it.

If all of this sounds a little too petty to be believed, just consider this: Bowen's replacement on the Parks board will be Bob Freid, whose record of public service (according to Google, in any event) is rather sparse, save only a public endorsement of ... you got it: Michelle Monte for School Board.

Kent Monte's role in this drama is a bit different. According to one of the comments on the NW thread (so take it with a grain of salt) he served as Esslinger's "campaign manager" or whatever. There's good reason to believe that Kent and Esslinger are of the same mind on a lot of issues, which would make him a good proxy for Paul. As it would happen, Esslinger is no longer allowed to sit on the Planning Commission now that he's Mayor, so there's just such an opening ready to be filled by just such a person.

And as luck would have it, Esslinger's departure coincides with the end of another member's term. During her time on the common council Shirley Maddox came to be identified with the -- ooooohhh, what ridiculous cliche would the Northwestern use that does the city no good and only serves to inflame divisions? oh, yeah -- "wine and cheese" crowd. By replacing her with Monte, Esslinger is pretty obviously throwing a bone to his base, which apparently exists at the opposite end of the Nebulously Defined Socioeconomic Foodstuffs Strata.
  • 4.) Why this is an indication of poor leadership.
As mayor, Esslinger is going to presumably have to work with people who disagree with him on various issues. In other words, Esslinger will not always have the luxury of simply appointing like-minded cronies to positions when they are held by people of a different opinion. If he can't get his way in the future, as is inevitable, how will he react?

The smart money is on "not well," but I'm going to put all my chips on "by taking his ball and going home."
  • 5.) Here's the thing: On one level this is just politics ... but on another, it's not.
Every new "executive" is going to appoint people he knows and trusts to positions that fall under his or her purview. The dirty little secret about the federal government is that there are probably thousands of people around the country who can successfully be the Secretary of the Interior, but the President is going to pick someone from that pool that he knows and trusts.

That's not necessarily "dirty politics" or a quid pro quo so much as responsible team building. You can get away with that at the federal and even state level, but not in a city like Oshkosh. We're too small and the talent pool is too shallow. Appointments start to become crooked when people are provided positions of power who aren't competent and/or when they replace people who are for politically motivated reasons. Time will tell if the former is true, but the current circumstance certainly suggest the latter is the case.

While there is definitely a dispassionate political angle to all of this, one that the current mayor clear understands, there is another that Esslinger seems hopelessly oblivious to: Politics is as much about common courtesy as it is about cold-blooded wrangling. That's a concept a classless boor like Esslinger clearly has no comprehension of and we're the poorer for it as a city.
  • 5.) Don't plan on seeing a new council member any time soon.
This is exactly the reason why we urged as much transparancy as humanly possibly during the selection of the next council member.

This is the first of what will surely be a long and distinguished line of Esslinger instigated distractions that will take the focus off of the real issues. If the council has to devote a ton of time to fixing appointments to boards, it certainly won't have the capacity to refill it's own bench. Actually, now the council must fix this mess before moving on to selecting a new member precisely because Esslinger has diminished the council's ability to make appointments by calling into question at least one member's ability to do so in good faith.

Bra. Vo.
  • 6.) Hey Northwestern, why not include a list of all the appointments Esslinger is submitting to the council?
Just a thought, it seems like it would be relevant to the story. [MORE: They've added a link since last I checked.]
  • 7.) There is every reason to believe this is how Paul Esslinger is going to behave throughout the rest of his term as Mayor.
Here it all is in a nut shell, folks. This is the kind of unforced error we should all get used to because we've seen it time and time again from Esslinger and he never quite seems to learn from his mistakes.

Now the question becomes: will the voters in Oshkosh eventually learn from theirs?

Sunday, April 12, 2009

How Esslinger Should Appoint the Next Member of the Council

So the NW has another editorial pushing for a Steve Cummings appointment to the council this morning. It's a lovely sentiment, but we're pretty sure it's not going to happen, so rather than continue advocating for an unlikelihood, maybe it's time to look at the reality of the situation.

The new council gets seated on April 21st -- nine days from now. If the council waits for a special election in November, the council will have six members for six months. That effectively creates a situation where what would normally be a three vote minority becomes enough to scuttle any given vote. That means Esslinger has to find three other votes until a full council is seated. By making an appointment to the council Esslinger essentially creates a second vote for himself, which means he only has to convince two other seats on the council to vote with him on any particular issue.

This is a no brainer.

So instead of worrying which one of the also-rans should fill the seat, we should perhaps start examining how the seat should be filled.

One way this could all be settled is by Esslinger showing up to his swearing in on the 21st and saying "I'm appointing X to the council, let's vote!" To the best of my knowledge, he has every right to do this. This may seem like an efficient way to correct the problem, but lacks any degree of transparency whatsoever.

Esslinger says he wants folks to submit resumes and that he'll make his decision from a pool of applications. He certainly has the ability to do that, but if he wants this process to have any legitimacy at all he's going to have to make the appointment out in the open.

Here's how we suggest he does this.

1.) Esslinger should come out with a target date for filling the seat and a deadline for submissions. We think May 15th or thereabouts is more than enough time to send resumes to City Hall and that the seat should be filled by the end of June. Sooner is fine, but if this process starts to take much longer it will likely be the result of far bigger issues.

2.) Applications should be open to the public. The city deserves to see who Esslinger thinks is qualified and who isn't. Ideally, we'd like to see all the submissions posted online. If one person is clearly head and shoulders above the rest of the field, then it should be obvious to most people and we can all move on to letting the council vote. Since we doubt such a candidate will emerge...

3.) Esslinger announces a group of "finalists." This will give the candidates a two to four week period to be interviewed by both the Mayor and the rest of the council and will allow each finalist's supporters to lobby the council members, write letters to the editor, etc. This will also give the rest of the city time to get to know each of the finalists though Q&A's in the NW and elsewhere. And all of this is good for the eventual appointee. Requiring the finalists to do a little campaigning will help them gain credibility in the eyes of the public. No one will be able to accuse the next council member of being just a lackey to the mayor, because he or she will have gone through a "mini-campaign" of sorts to win the position. (This works both ways; the mayor gets some cover by appointing someone who had to work for the gig and not just a relative or drinking buddy or whatever.)

In a lot of ways, this is following the same sort of formula the council uses in selecting a city manager. We don't feel it should be that complicated or protracted a process, but what has been outlined above essentially combines an appointment process with a special election and in so doing removes the transparency issues associated with the former and the prohibitive cost of the latter.

Of course, we'd prefer to see the rules changed so that there is never an appointment to the council, but since those aren't the rules right now, we'll settle for this.

Tuesday, April 7, 2009

Be Careful What You Ask For...

With 26 of 40 precincts reporting Paul Esslinger is leading Frank Tower by about 750 votes -- so I think we can safely put this one to bed.

This doesn't come as huge to surprise to us here at the Chief. After nine years on the city council Essingler has nothing to show for his tenure except a string of polarizing incidents that do little in terms of moving the city forward, but are a great way of getting one's name in the paper. Tower's mild-mannered approach to governance was simply no match for Esslinger, who is not afraid to to get all up in the grills of his colleagues. We find this unfortunate, but, again, not surprising.

So what does this mean? Quite a bit actually. An elected mayor of Oshkosh was initially described as little more than a figurehead with ceremonial responsibilities beyond those of any other council person. As mayor, Tower walked a fine and cautious line trying to adhere to that principle, and likely for the better. Simply by virtue of being elected Esslinger destroys that quaint notion of the position now that he has the power to appoint another vote to the council. This will be Esslinger first test as Mayor, one that won't merely set the pace for the rest of his term in office, but will likely define it.

We personally feel this is a major flaw in the way the mayor is choosen in Oshkosh. By running for mayor, Esslinger didn't stand to lose his seat on the council whereas Tower did. Furthermore, a Tower win would have resulted in a continuation of the status quo in terms of council composition, but an Esslinger win now results in a radical shift in the council's make-up. The stakes of this particular race are tremendously off kilter, as we can now plainly see.

To that end, we feel Esslinger's first act as mayor should be appointing his replacement through any manner he sees fit. We don't agree with the makeshift "instant run-off" method endorsed by the NW -- it's no less arbitrary than Esslinger chosing a cousin for the job. The people of Oshkosh were asked to choose three council members, not four. Had four council seat been on the line, as we believe there should have been, this would have radically changed the way many people in Oshkosh would have voted. Esslinger chosing the fourth place finisher of tonight's election will only result in the verneer of legitimacy.

What needs to happen is the adoption of a "sore loser" policy. If the Mayor's office is going to be treated differently from other council position -- as is clearly happening -- it should be an all or nothing affair. If you run for Mayor, you can't run for council. If you're already on the council, you have to give up your seat to run for Mayor. Esslinger potentially wins two council votes by becoming mayor -- that simply should never be an issue during an election of this nature. This is a loophole that obviously needs to be closed and should be the second thing Esslinger should accomplish in office.

We admit these are not life and death issues, but will require the leadership needed by an effective mayor who plans on accomplishing much else while in office.

Following these minor, but necessary, changes to the council, Esslinger claimed (rather inconsistantly, it should be noted) that his top priorities are, depending on when he was being asked:
  • Public Safety
  • Sewage Treatment
  • Jobs
  • Infrastucture
By all estimates, Oshkosh will likely be heading into a troubled economic period in the foreseeable future. Crime increases when that happens. Tax revenues decline. Jobs become scarce. During his time on the council Esslinger never once spearheaded a movement to enhance any of these areas. He may have voted on this motion or that ordinance, but he's never led the charge on anything. We don't expect that to change.

Esslinger has always wanted to be mayor, but he's won the job at a time that requires real leadership, leadership that he has consistenlty demonstrated he is incapable of providing. We anticipate that he will look for guidance and excuses elsewhere. In fact, we think the city of Oshkosh should get used to hearing two phrases "The survey said the people want ..." and "There's nothing that the mayor can really do about ..." Surveys are fine tools, but what happens when a 30% plurality wants one thing and another 30% wants something else? What happens when 35% want something silly and 30% want something serious? Those are the moments when leaders step up and, you know, lead. We won't expect to be surprised when we don't see any of this during Esslinger's term.

But that's just big thinking. What should Oshkosh expect to see in the next two years? Not much. A lot of talk about this and that -- but in terms of specifics, not much.

Sewage Treatment: Little does Esslinger realize, but he's walking into a mine field here. If he wants to enhance the city's treatment capacities he will have to raise taxes and/or fees. If he doesn't manage to sell this idea -- as opposed to just bagging it in the face of opposition from tax advocates -- he will then be faced with where to begin the enhancements. Choose the west side and the rest of the city will be pissed because they have all the development going on already. Choose the south side and the rest of the city will be pissed because Esslinger lives there. Choose the north side and, well, you get the picture. All the sewage lip service Esslinger gave was basically an example of him having his cake and eating it too: it's a far more complicated problem than he is aware of, one that requires some degree of skill and salesmanship to negotiate. There's no evidence to suggest Esslinger has that skill, so we feel there's no reason anything will change on this front. Unless it's funded by federal stimulus money, don't expect it to happen in Oshkosh.

Infrastructure: Ditto the above. If you're expecting the street to suddenly be paved with gold, we are sorry to disappoint you. The NW put it rather succinctly in its endorsement of Tower last week:

What can you make of a politician who said he wants more money spent on infrastructure, but votes against the city's capital improvement program? Esslinger said he wanted more dollars earmarked for streets and sewers. Fair enough. But he did not offer a single amendment to accomplish that. All he did was offer an amendment to remove floating docks from Riverside Park.

After nine years on the Common Council, Esslinger should recognize that the time to chart out a comprehensive shift in public works projects isn't a "No" vote in November. It takes leadership in January, February and March to set goals and direct staff to begin planning to accomplish them.

That about says it all.

Public Safety: Watch for it to rise, but through no fault of Esslinger's. Crime rates rise during tough economic times regardless of who is in charge, but don't be surprised if an incident or series of incidents (invasion of the tire vampires, perhaps?) inspires Esslinger to flex his mayoral muscles through some meaningless grandstanding.

Jobs: Don't plan on Esslinger cutting many ribbons in front of newly opening businesses any time soon. Jobs will come to Oshkosh, but it will largely have nothing to do with what happens at City Hall. If an enterprising journalist wanted to start a recurring column, he or she might want to keep a running count of how many jobs Esslinger creates during his tenure. We're talking about private sector jobs provided by companies that relocate or expand here in Oshkosh and that publically disclose Esslinger's role in the creation of those jobs.

Downtown Redevelopment: On hold until further notice. Expect the news today that Water City Grill is closing to be the beginning of a string of bad news for downtown. There will be hard times for Main Street on the way, but Esslinger has made clear that we've sunk enough into that part of town already, so ... you all are on your own.

Riverside: I hope everyone likes the sight of an expansive empty field where potentially profitably waterfront property could be located, because that's what we're all going to be getting for the foreseeable future. The riverfront seemed to be plagued by a lack of vision and awful proposals -- and that was when it was a priority of the council. There's no reason to believe any active effort will be made to change this.

City Government: At various times Esslinger will almost certainly recommend an increase in City Government, like he has in the past with the addition of a "Development Divison" to City Hall. These will come with little regard to expense or how they will be implemented and will be little more than Esslinger delegating authority that should be the responsibility of the mayor or other government employees.

The Office of the Mayor: Whereas Mayor Tower was careful to not to overextend the authority of the mayor's office, Esslinger will suffer from no such compunction. Expect him to try to expand the reach of the mayor without much consideration for the long term consequences. He's said so much himself:
My vision for the office would be to have a person that is elected by the citizens and has more influence. This person would also be in charge of going to Madison to lobby our state legislature to the needs of Oshkosh. This person should also have an office where citizens could contact him/her during business hours to help them with issues that confront them with city government.
That sounds like Esslinger wants to make this a full time gig. Expect him to try, but not get very far doing so.

Letters to the Editor: There will be tons, many over remarkably stupid distractions instigated by Esslinger. Likewise with editorials. This will go on and on and on until further notice.

Last, but not least, Esslinger can almost be certainly credited with the creation of a vehement opposition that will critique decisions and actions that would have otherwise gone unnoticed by Mayor of yore. That is his own damn fault. Esslinger egged on many people in Oshkosh and now those people get to sit back and snipe from the sidelines. Expect the criticism to be relentless and the demand to perform to be just as intense.

We here at the Chief expect nothing short of epic failure from Esslinger. We hope for otherwise, but have little reason to believe that's going to happen.

MORE: It's official -- the NW calls it.

Thursday, July 19, 2007

What's Wrong With This Picture?

This letter that arrived in the NW's mailbox is peculiar -- to say the absolute least: someone from across the country chiming in to the local paper on an issue that couldn't possibly be more parochial and, not surprisingly, is entirely off base.

For your consideration:

Esslinger takes lead on getting council information

Thank you, (Councilor Paul) Esslinger, for expressing your concern about lack of information flow to the council.

Now if only the rest of the council would make (Community Development Director) Jackson Kinney and (City Manager) Richard Wollangk accountable for informing the entire council, as soon as pertinent information is received.

Today's situation about (Ben) Ganther and his problems is just the latest in a long string of situations that, over the years, never seem to shared with the council in a timely manner. Perhaps Mr. Kinney and Mr. Wollangk have been in their positions a little too long and their authority has gone to their heads. Whatever the reasons for not providing sufficient information to the entire council, it should be stopped immediately and those involved should be held accountable.

Frances Woldt Cottonwood, Ariz.

What a crock of shit!

First of all, why does the author seem to have the impression that Councilman Esslinger – and only Paul Esslinger! – has had a hand in calling for accountability? Did accountability suddenly become a controversial issue or something that requires an advanced degree (or relevant expertise) to implement?

Here’s some excerpts from last Sunday’s NW:

"It should be an expectation," said councilor Bryan Bain. "We've shown where information wasn't provided. We asked for changes to be made. Over time, it creates an impression that staff is trying to keep information from the council. When there's a perception like that, it's a problem."

And,

Councilor Jessica King said the problem should be discussed by councilors at their next meeting, but questions if that's sufficient.

"At what point do we go into closed session to review the role of the city manager?" King said. "When is 'enough is enough?'"

(emphasis added)

And here is Dennis McHugh taking the whole matter to a place it probably doesn’t need to go.


So what exactly does Ms. Francis Woldt of Cottonwood, Arizona mean when she says “Now if only the rest of the council would make (Community Development Director) Jackson Kinney and (City Manager) Richard Wollangk accountable for informing the entire council, as soon as pertinent information is received”?

It sound to me like a good chunk of council is plenty pissed off about the matter and is indeed looking for accountability…

Which leads me to my crackpot conspiracy theory of the day:

This letter has the manufactured feel of a letter used to promote a candidate running for office during election time and given some of the heat Esslinger’s gotten for his last epistle to the masses (my take on that lovely opus is here), I’m thinking the councilman was in need of a little good press. So he calls up an old friend or relative for a chat, explains the situation and then drops a few subtle hints about how someone really ought to get his back on this one and maybe drop the old Northwestern a line…

Obviously, this is idle conjecture – and it’s wild speculation at that. I can’t prove a goddamn thing, nor am I inclined to devote all that much time into doing so, but this letter is pure bullshit. If someone has to import their support from out of town, then maybe it’s time to follow the followers.