Showing posts with label Rudy Giuliani. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rudy Giuliani. Show all posts

Thursday, January 31, 2008

Who is Screwing Up the GOP?

Well, everyone, really ... Talk radio, the evangelicals, FOX, the whole think tank apparatus in DC -- you name it, they are probably doing something stupid even as we speak.

But here's segment of the Grand ol' Coalition that you don't hear about getting much flak: the consultants. These guys have done pretty well for themselves in recent memory but you really have to start asking yourself, "What, exactly, the fuck are they up to these days?"

This was a problem the Democrats had for seemingly ever, but it appears to be endemic among Republicans this year. Here's what John Heilemann had to say about Rudy's demise:

There are two broad prevailing theories about how Giuliani lost his mojo. The first revolves around the campaign that he and his team engineered. It contends that he was nuts to effectively blow off the first month of the nominating process and to place all his chips on Florida. That his operation was insular and parochial, dominated by his old City Hall inner circle. That its expenditures were out of control. As John Ellis asks at RealClearPolitics, “Where did all of Giuliani’s money go? He raised, as I understand it, roughly $45 million. He competed in one primary. He did not spend $45 million in Florida … How much were his consultants paid? The ones who dreamed up the ‘don’t-compete-and-win’ strategy? How much (in percentage terms) went to private aviation?”

[The second prevailing theory is, as we here at the Chief have said before, that Giuliani's a dick.]

Private aviation? That's not a small detail -- and it's important for a campaign to have it's own transportation -- but I'll bet Rudy was flying just as well as he liked to do before he started running. Here's the funny part about the flying business: the guy who's going to win the GOP nomination -- John McCain -- was flying coach just a few months ago. And so was the guy who might be his running mate ...

And perhaps now would be a good time to remind everyone that the reason McCain was flying coach in the first place was because of his ... wait for it ... consultants. They had sucked his campaign coffers dry and then split when the going got rough. In fact, McCain's mid-summer's campaign staff massacre was probably the best thing that happened to him this year, a strange sort of blessing in disguise that forced him to get back to the basics that made him popular in the first place.

Katie Rosenberg was on to something when she pointed out the NY Times postmortem on Giuliani ... it'd be interesting to see if she has anything more to add.

Anyway, there's a theory of warfare that runs something like this: it doesn't matter what the advantages one side might have -- technology, intelligence, even numbers -- they will always lose to an opponent with more fight in their belly. Right now it seems like the size of the fight in the GOP's consultancy class is minimal and that will mean, no matter who the nominee is, Republicans are going to get slaughtered in November.

Tuesday, January 29, 2008

Giuliani Done

Rudy will endorse McCain sometime soon.

There will likely be a lot of postmortems but here's the short version:

Crappy Candidate.
Crappy Advisers.
Crappy Electoral Strategy.
Crappy Media Strategy.
Crappy Fundraising Effort.

Rudy was living on borrowed time almost from the get-go, it just took GOP voters a long time to figure that out. Almost every other candidate out-shines Giuliani in some way: McCain's foreign policy experience is stronger, Huckabee is more approachable and funnier, Romney's management skills in the private sector are more extensive, and Rudy's conservative heresies are far more plentiful than all of them put together.

Rudy Death Watch: Day 19 (Cont.)


Rudy's killing time by doing doing some phone-banking today and getting shelled by the press (who have some more details on the Charlie Crist endorsement). He's acknowledged this whole Florida thing maybe wasn't the best idea. Republican bloggers are turning on him.

And James Antle at the American Spectator remind us all where this started: "Until the news broke that some Giuliani staffers were forgoing paychecks, we didn't tend to think of that campaign as having problems."

Hey, that's when we started our Rudy Death Watch ...

Rudy Death Watch: Day 19 (Cont.)

Craig Crawford is talking with Joe Scarborough right now on TV and just made the most succinct assessment of Giuliani's campaign you will find anywhere:

Scarborough: What happened with Giuliani's campaign?

Crawford: He campaigned. Everywhere he went his numbers went down.

There. That's it. That's all you need to know about the Giuliani campaign in a nutshell. Crawford went on to explain that Rudy would give the same stump speech to college students in Iowa that he would give to old women in New Hampshire. In some ways, Crawford said, Giuliani was just as lazy as Fed Thompson. I couldn't agree more, but Crawford also has to factor in the small detail that Giuliani is a dick. Obama can probably get away with giving the same stump speech to different demographics (though he's certainly smarter than that) -- Guiliani can not. He's too abrasive and awkward and on at least a subconscious level this rubs people the wrong way.

Rudy Death Watch: Day 19


I'll be astonished if Rudy's still around by the end of the day. We said a few weeks ago that he had the most to lose of all the Presidential candidates and we're sticking to that -- this loss will be epic. At the beginning of November he was a shoe-in -- hell, we didn't see how he could lose ... The last few weeks, however, have shown us that the GOP deserves a lot of credit for seeing through Giuliani's bullshit.

Bottom line is that Rudy needed to make this a "national" campaign and he can't do that. In fact, I doubt he ever could do that. He simply did not have the money.

Monday, January 28, 2008

Rudy Death Watch: Day 18 (Concluded)


Chuck Todd was just on TV observing that the aforementioned good-bye gifts are as good as any indicator that Rudy's gone after tomorrow.

He also noted that instead of "going down in a blaze of glory" Rudy played nice these last few weeks to keep his business viable ...

I'll have plenty more to say about that tomorrow.

Rudy Death Watch: Day 18 (Cont.)


Man, I thought being compared to the Titanic was rough, but being compared to Phil Gramm ... that's just harsh.

Today has not been a good day for Hizzoner. He's losing the support of the New York Post, reporters are asking him if he's still going to be in the race on Wednesday, and he's saying he's going to win Florida like it's actually going to happen. Giuliani's campaign also seems to be giving away "going away gifts" to his press gaggle.

And now he's even hinting that he is not long for this world.

Rudy Death Watch: Day 18

Comparisons to the Titanic aside, Rudy's last ditch effort in Florida seems to be relying heavily exclusively on New York ex-pats. Not that these voters are unimportant, but it seems ridiculous to me hang all hope on such a slim niche. In some ways this really encapsulates the "big idea" of Rudy's campaign in so far as he frequently seemed to be running for the President of New York and not America.

There's a lot wrong with Rudy's run, but the death nail was of his own doing:

The fascinating thing about Giluliani's collapse is that it is primarily attributable to a strategic error, the decision to avoid contests in early states. It's not as though another candidate caught fire and displaced Rudy; McCain's return from the dead was largely a result of a vacuum created in no small part by Giuliani's occlusion, and the candidate who really did come out of nowhere, Mike Huckabee, took votes from Rudy's rivals. And while Rudy did take some hits late last year over his tangled love life and its possible impact on NY taxpayers, much of that was old news, and it accompanied the fall in the polls more than it caused it. He's done pretty well in the debates, and in fundraising. But it hasn't mattered much.

I'm willing to buy this, but only if it comes with a side order of "Rudy's a crappy retail politician."

Saturday, January 26, 2008

Rudy Death Watch: Day 17


You know you're in trouble when people who once committed their endorsements to you start to renege:

Giuliani campaign sources said [Florida Gov. Charlie] Crist pledged his endorsement to Giuliani in the early fall, when McCain’s campaign appeared dead and Giuliani was leading the state by double digits. But at the time, McCain supporters leaned on Crist to hold back and wait until after the New Hampshire primary. McCain had campaigned for Crist when he was seeking the Republican nomination for governor, and had hoped Crist would return the favor.

More here on how the "Florida Firewall" strategy has failed miserably.

Rudy Death Watch: Day 16


The NYPD endorsed ... John McCain today, an act that Michael Crowley is calling Rudy's "penultimate humiliation."

At least Giuliani still has the support of America's favorite quasi-vigilante psuedo-paramilitary group ...

Wednesday, January 23, 2008

Who Wins, Who Loses: Fred Thompson Edition

Let's just get right down to business, shall we?

LOSERS

Rep. Zach Wamp: He was the one who put this sham of campaign together in the first place by co-chairing the Draft Thompson movement. To a degree you kind of have to admire the guy: he saw there was no clear GOP front-runner and did what he could to promote the candidacy of a fellow Tennassean. It was a bold and gutsy maneuver to try and play king-maker that would have propelled him from being a second-tier congressman to being a major player ... if it would have worked.

Rep. Steve King: He was going to endorse Mitt Romney, then at the last minute changed his mind and endorsed Thompson. Way to go, dipshit ...

The Pro-Life Movement: Largely put their support behind Thompson across the country, including here in Wisconsin. These groups may choose to eventually back another candidate, but there's little reason to expect that they'll have as much influence with a new guy since they weren't on board to begin with.

Rudy Giuliani: See Mike Huckabee below. Rudy will not only lose Florida, but he now may come in a truly embarrassing fourth place. Making matters worse is that now when journalists want to kick around a truly awful campaign, they'll look to Rudy.

Anyone who says this race is better for having Fred Thompson in it: Please ... Bill Kramer, Brandon Henak -- who are you guys trying to fool? No one drafted Fred Thompson into this race because they liked his stance on the issues. Quick, what was the major issue he was running on? Anyone? Anyone? Buehler? Beuhler? People turned to Fred because he was an actor and thought he might pull Ronald Reagan out of his ass. No one was looking for issues from this guy, they were looking for gravitas and presence, of which Fred apparently had little. Let's not try to pretend that the Thompson campaign was of any consequence other than a large waste of time.


WINNERS:

Jeri Thompson: Where Fred disappointed, his wife did her all to pick up the slack. It was a valiant effort that underscores just how little Fred wanted to do this. We'll likely be seeing more of her, possibly even without Fred ... Some will point to her as the undoing of the campaign, but that's almost wholly immaterial. She demonstrated that she was the power behind someone who just couldn't be made to run for office.

Journalists, pundits and commentators who called Thompson lazy: Hey, when the media gets one right they deserve some credit and they got this one right all the way back in April. If anything, the press underestimated just how lazy Thompson turned out to be.

Mike Huckabee: Likely to be the beneficiary of the Southern evangelical voters that originally went with Fred.

Rep. Nathan Deal: Was planning on endorsing Thompson, but thought better at the last minute. Many of Thompson's congressional endorsements were so underwhelmed with his performance that some were speaking privately about rescinding.

Ron Paul: ... but only in a minor way. It now looks like Rudy won't last much longer after Florida, which will make his precipitous decline in the polls truly epic. I'm talking about the stuff of campaign legend, a ghost story political operatives will tell their interns when they want to motivate them. There's a good chance that Paul will last longer and round up more delegates to the GOP convention then Rudy, which makes Giuliani's taunting of Paul during the early debate seem foolishly unwise now.

Jim Mills & Mark Corallo: Thompson campaign staffers who were smart enough to jump ship back in September, before he had even announced his candidacy.

Linus Roache: When Thompson left Law & Order, Sam Waterson got promoted to District Attorney, thus creating an opening for an A.D.A. There isn't a struggling actor on Earth that wouldn't kill a busload of nuns for that role and the kind of exposure it comes with. I don't know if Roache exactly had to kill a busload of nuns, but he did land a coveted acting gig.

Monday, January 21, 2008

Rudy Death Watch: Day 11


Yikes ...

Rudy Giuliani's campaign doesn't just suck, it sucks something fierce:

[I]t's noteworthy just how awfully Rudy has fared in the lead-off contests. Last night, he finished with 2 percent of the vote in South Carolina, a state where he'd been running near the top of polls just a few months ago. And yesterday afternoon, he won just 1,910 votes in Nevada—good for four percent.

His best showing to date was in New Hampshire, where he nearly broke double-digits (9 percent). Between Iowa, New Hampshire, Michigan, Nevada and South Carolina he has managed to win just 60,212 votes—or 15,000 fewer than he received when he defeated Ron Lauder in the 1989 Republican mayoral primary. By contrast, Ron Paul—whom Giuliani has verbally battered in an effort to impress the G.O.P. base—has received 106,387 votes so far.

MORE: Here, here and here. And here's a chart showing his poll numbers for the last 7 months.

Wednesday, January 16, 2008

America's Mayor Can Go Screw Himself

Rudy just lost doesn't give a shit about Wisconsin:

Rudy Giuliani refused to sign a potential voter’s Green Bay Packers hat after a campaign stop Monday afternoon, saying it would be “bad luck.”

The loyal New York Giants fan denied the request as he was signing autographs and posing for photos after a meet and greet at the Village Fish Market and Restaurant on day two of his bus tour through the Sunshine State. While Florida has become the campaign’s must-win state, Giuliani is apparently drawing a line as to how far he will go to woo voters.

“I won’t sign that,” he said after campaign chairman Pat Oxford handed him the hat. “No, no, no. That would be bad luck right now.”

The Giants are set to play the Packers in the NFC Championship game on Sunday and Giuliani is a life-long fan of his hometown team.

“I’ll sign it after (the game),” Giuliani told the man as he instead signed another supporters’ Giants visor. But the Packers fan was relentless, again demanding Giuliani “sign it now!” Giuliani refused the request after which the man could be heard grunting.

(emphasis added)

Are you fucking kidding me?!?

I mean, it's one thing to sell out and root for the Red Sox, but then to suddenly rediscover the New Yorker in you after you get your ass kicked in Iowa ... and New Hampshire ... and Michigan ...



Sorry, Tommy Thompson ... My condolences, Cathy Stepp & Scott Klug ... Christian Schneider, I loved your post about this weekend's Packer game, but you have to do something about this picture immediately.

I expect your resignations on my desk by tomorrow morning.

Monday, January 14, 2008

Giuliani Death Watch: Day 4

Sweet Jesus:

Rudy Giuliani began his Sunday in an unusual place for him - at church - and with an unusual fellow congregant, the controversial former Florida Secretary of State Katherine Harris.

(emphasis added)

Katherine Harris ... !

Friday, January 11, 2008

Giuliani Death Watch Begins ... Now

Maybe you heard that Giuliani's campaign staff was giving up their paychecks this month to keep the campaign flush with cash ... Turns out that it's only a dozen or so members of the staff, but that still doesn't correct the fact that Rudy is now behind in the make-or-break state of Florida.

I think this is where we officially start to say good bye to Hizzoner.

MORE: Giuliani just lost his National Finance Chair too. That can't be good on a day when the campaign is trying to convince people it's not having money problems.

EVEN MORE: Part of the reason Giuliani stands to lose much of his support is that foreign affairs are quickly being displaced by domestic issues as priorities for voters. If terrorism, the war in Iraq or the situation with Iran suddenly recapture the public's consciousness Giuliani might be able to reposition himself as a more viable candidate. This, however, will not help.

MORE STILL: Here are some raw numbers on just how underwhelming Giuliani's money-raising effort has been:

A Giuliani campaign news release today brought word that at the end of 2007 he had $12.7 million cash on hand, but only about $7 million of that could be used in the primaries. That is nowhere near enough to seriously compete in the 22 states that vote on Feb. 5.

[...]

The former mayor launched his presidential bid with the goal of raising more than $100 million in 2007. He didn't come even close. ... Figures for fourth-quarter donations, always the toughest money-raising quarter, are not due to be reported to the Federal Election Commission until the end of this month. ...

By the end of September, Giuliani had gathered in only $44.3 million, with $16.6 million in the bank.

Thursday, January 10, 2008

More Bad News for Rudy

Far and away the most amazing implosion of this year's campaign has to be that of Rudy Giuliani, who has decided to pull out of the Michigan Primary. Rudy's retooled campaign was supposed to bank on doing well in the big states where media is expensive and retail politicking was de rigueur. Theoretically speaking, Michigan should be one of those states.

Rudy's biggest mistake was abandoning New Hampshire. Giuliani bombed in Iowa spectacularly. As cliche as it sounds Rudy was simply to New York to get by in the Midwest. I recall one account of Hizzoner actually trying to talk crop rotation strategies (or something of that nature) to a farmer who was extremely underwhelmed. That should have told him to pull up stakes and head to New England.

The problem is that New Hampshire is a retail politics state. Assholes don't do well when it comes to retail politics, and Rudy Giuliani is a colossal asshole.

He had the votes and the people who wanted to vote for him -- all he had to do was put a smile on his face, laugh at a few bad jokes, and nod a few times while shaking hands ... and he couldn't do it. He's been lost in the shuffle of the excitement of the primaries and won't be back in the news until February 5th January 29th. In the meantime, all of his GOP opponents have been sucking in the earned media oxygen. He may be leading in the national primary, but every state that holds a primary has that Rudy subsequently abandons in turn leaves him.

Why should all of this matter? Isn't this just another case of the American electoral system weeding out the unfit? Possibly, but Giuliani had the most to lose of anyone running for president this year -- I would argue even more than Hillary Clinton does -- and watching him fall is like watching the birth of a bed time story parents tell their kids abut the nature of Hubris. Rudy could have lived out the rest of his days as "America's Mayor," bringing six figures per speech, and advising Presidents (both Democratic and Republican). But after this election Rudy may just be known as the guy who blew his chance at the Presidency.

Then again, Rudy's Florida Firewall gambit just might work:

The good news for Mr. Giuliani is that, with McCain’s win Tuesday, the Republican field remains a morass of flawed candidates, which means that by the time Super Tuesday rolls around, he could conceivably find himself in a position to compete for the nomination, after all. It’s not a very promising strategy, however. “The more impossible you tell me something is, the more likely I am to do it,” I heard Mr. Giuliani boast to an audience this week. Maybe that means he’s about to shock us all. Or maybe it means that running a coherent campaign was just too possible a feat to interest him.

Wednesday, December 5, 2007

Is Mitt Romney a Mormon or a Luddite?

Why doesn't he "write" (or in this case, "edit") his speeches on a keyboard like a normal Christian?

(Pictured above: the heathen Romney examines the runic incantations of the sorcerer's spell his minions have prepared for him to recite before the television cameras tomorrow.)

Seriously, the fact that Romney has to give a Mormon speech in 21st Century America is one of two things: 1.) embarrassing, or 2.) indicative of broader problems Romney has as a candidate -- and by that I mean GOP voters are transferring his inherent untrustability as a Massachusetts flip-flopper into suspicions about his religion (but for reasons that entirely escape me).

That being said, how's this for a wild scenario: Romney's speech bombs and sends his campaign into unrecoverable tailspin, Giuliani's woes continue to dog him and subsequently drag his nomination under, Huckabee's rise is halted by questions about how tough on crime he is and his national security credentials, while the Thompson campaign spends the next 6 weeks calling for their candidate with a team of bloodhounds in the Great Smokey Mountains ... Does all of that mean that John McCain might have a chance to slip through the wreckage and past the finish line in New Hampshire, thus giving him the momentum need to propel him to the nomination?

I don't know, but watching a four car pile-up just before the end of the race would be fucking awesome!

Saturday, December 1, 2007

Where There's Smoke, There's Fire

I don't think I've ever seen a week this bad.

That's kind of the thing with Rudy: it's never just one thing. Bad news seems to come in droves when Giuliani's involved.

Tuesday, November 27, 2007

Wisconsin Presidential Campaign Staffs and Endorsements

I've done some gathering of presidential endorsements by Wisconsin bloggers in the past (latest update here), and yesterday I saw a press release that got me thinking it might be a good idea to start collecting where other prominent Wisconsinites are devoting their political loyalty.

Here's what I got thus far: Frankly, it's a list I'm not very satisfied with, but it's the best I could do with limited time and energy. Any help that can add to this would be a greatly appreciated.

So without further ado ...

Mitt Romney

Wisconsin Statewide Finance Steering Committee

David Beightol – Managing Principal, Dutko Worldwide
Scott Beightol – Attorney, Michael Best & Friedrich LLP
Joe Chrnelich – Director of Sales, Verax Corporation
Terence “Terry” Dittrich – International Sales Manager, Spancrete Machinery Corp.
Curt Geilow – President, Gielow Associates, Inc.
Jay Hintze – Vice President, Heartland Development Group
Helen Johnson – Chairman & CEO, Johnson Outdoors and Chairman, Johnson Financial Corporation
James Klauser – Former Senior Vice President, We Energies
Elaine Kraut – Owner and President, Genesee Aggregate Corporation
Craig Leipold – CEO, Nashville Predators
Mary Reid – Senior Government Affairs Adviser, We Energies
Paul Sweeney – Investor, PS Capital Partners

U.S. Rep. Tom Petri


Rudy Giuliani

Former Gov. Tommy Thompson
Former U.S. Sen. Bob Kasten, foreign policy advisory team
Former State Sen. Cathy Stepp & former U.S. Rep. Scott Klug, state campaign co-chairs


Hillary Clinton

Rep. Tammy Baldwin, state campaign co-chair
Lt. Gov. Barbara Lawton, Midwest campaign co-chair
Kathleen Falk, Dane County Executive*
Matt Flynn, Former Chair of the Wisconsin Democratic Party, Milwaukee Attorney*
Tom Loftus, Former Speaker of the Wisconsin Assembly and Ambassador to Norway*
Nancy Nusbaum, Former Brown County Executive and Mayor of DePere*
Brady Williamson, Madison Attorney*
Georgia Duerst-Lahti, Beloit College Professor, Commentator*
Kate Peyton, Activist and Organizer*
Jackie Boynton, Founder, Women's Choice, Milwaukee Attorney*
Karen Campbell, Milwaukee Community Leader*
Heather Colburn, Interim Director, FAIR Wisconsin*
Janis Ringhand, Former Evansville Mayor*
Bill Broydrick, Former State Assembly Member, Founder Broydrick & Associates*
*


Barak Obama

Rep. Gwen Moore
Jeff Neubauer, former state party chairman [helped organize fund-raiser]


John Edwards

Congressman and Chairman of the House Appropriation Committee David Obey
State Treasurer Dawn Marie Sass
Madison Mayor Dave Cieslewicz
Former Governor Tony Earl
Public Service Commissioner Mark Meyer
State Senator and Co-Chair of the Committee on Joint Finance Russ Decker
State Senator Jon Erpenbach
State Senator Bob Jauch
State Senator John Lehman
State Senator Bob Wirch
State Representative Jennifer Shilling
State Representative and Former Majority Leader David Travis
State Representative Amy Sue Vruwink
State Representative Sondy Pope-Roberts
State Representative Donna Seidel
State Representative Mike Sheridan, UAW Local 95 President
2nd Vice Chair of State Democratic Party of Wisconsin, Dottie LeClair
Wisconsin Democratic Party Chair Joe Wineke
State Representative Frank Boyle
State Representative Kim Hixson
State Representative Josh Zepnick
Wisconsin Democratic Party 2nd Vice Chair, Winnebago County Chair Jef Hall
Wisconsin Democratic Party Secretary Angela Sutkiewicz
8th Congressional District Administrative Committee Dottie LeClair
1st Congressional District Chair Ray Rivera
2nd CD Vice Chair, Dane County Democratic Party Executive Board Member, Peter Rickman
Former Executive Director of the Wisconsin Democratic Party, Dane County Democratic Party Executive Board member Don Jones
Former Executive Director of the Wisconsin Democratic Party Steve Kean
Dane County Democratic Party Chair Wayne Bigelow
Columbia County Democratic Party Chair Sara Lloyd
Fond du Lac County Democratic Party Chair Rich Mantz
Rock County Democratic Party Chair Tim Rutter
Waukesha County Democratic Party Chair Vic Weers
Washburn County Democratic Party Chair Susan Hansen
Portage County Democratic Party Co-Chair, 7th CD Administrative Committee Member, Greg Hawley
Portage County Democratic Party Co-Chair Lois Lawler
Former Democratic Nominee for the 5th Congressional District Bryan Kennedy
Lake Geneva City Council Member, Alderman Mary Jo Fessenmaier
Portage County Democratic Party Executive Board Member Charlene Figge
Marquette County Democratic Party Chair Jan Banicki
[All Edwards endorsements can be found here.]

Like I said, I know there more names out there, I've just had a hard time finding them -- but it's a start ...

UPDATE: Tony Palmeri notes that Milwaukee Mayor Tom Barrett, local Rep. Gordon Hintz, and Gus Doyle (the Gov.'s son) have endorsed Obama.